Afghan National Army commando recruits participate in a foot march during the Commando Selection and Assessment Course on Nov. 19, 2013, on Camp Commando near Kabul, Afghanistan.

Afghan National Army commando recruits participate in a foot march during the Commando Selection and Assessment Course on Nov. 19, 2013, on Camp Commando near Kabul, Afghanistan. (Michael J. Carden/U.S. Army)

HERAT, Afghanistan — Iran’s recruitment of Afghan men from the regions along the common border to fight in Syria, may be contributing to a shortage of Army recruits in western Afghanistan, NATO officials have said.

The Afghan security forces have struggled to keep their numbers up across the country, faced with record casualties in battle with the Taliban, desertions and phantom soldiers — names on the payrolls who may be dead or missing.

However, recruitment numbers are particularly low in Herat and neighbor provinces in western Afghanistan. The region is the most stable in the country, but if that changes as the Taliban spread their insurgency beyond their southern strongholds, Afghan forces in the region may not be up to the challenge, coalition officials said.

“If Afghanistan recruiting command can’t keep pace, that’s a problem,” said U.S. Army Col. Steve Lutsky, deputy commander of NATO’s Train Advise Assist Command-West.

Because Afghan forces are so strapped in other parts of the country, the area around Herat could not count on reinforcements, officials said.

Speaking with a select group of reporters at the command’s headquarters in the province, Lutsky said Iran may be partly to blame for the shortage.

“We believe they are recruiting Afghan males to fight ISIS in Syria,” he said, using an acronym for the Islamic State group. “That’s what we’ve been told by multiple people, which is one of the reasons why our recruiting is low in this area.”

Lutsky said he could understand why some Afghans would enlist.

“Iran pays better than the Afghan army, and you don’t have to potentially fight your family members,” he said.

Italian army Col. Roberto Viglietta, whose county heads TACC-West, agreed. “There is a lot of Iran in [the] region.”

In January, Human Rights Watch reported Iran had recruited thousands of Afghan refugees and migrants living in the country to join pro-government militias fighting in Syria, offering financial incentives and legal residence. In some cases, Afghans said they were threatened with deportation to Afghanistan, if they refused. Iran dismissed the report calling it “fabricated.”

However, Viglietta said other factors contributed to low recruitment numbers.

The region’s relatively good economy, compared to other areas, means many western Afghans can work for family businesses or choose other non-life-threatening jobs. A good schooling system, including graduate programs, allows locals to become qualified doctors, lawyers and engineers, careers that provide higher wages than the Afghan military.

Another hurdle is that the military cannot promise new recruits they will stay in the region, as many are sent where they are needed for the fight.

Maj. Gen. Mohiuddin Ghori, commander of the Afghan army’s 207 Corps in Herat, played down NATO’s recruitment concerns.

“Mostly in Afghanistan every season is different,” he said.

“For the moment, it’s not a tangible problem,” Ghori said. “But we should work a lot on this issue ... to increase numbers.” Twitter: @PhillipWellman

author picture
Phillip is a reporter and photographer for Stars and Stripes, based in Kaiserslautern, Germany. From 2016 to 2021, he covered the war in Afghanistan from Stripes’ Kabul bureau. He is a graduate of the London School of Economics.

Sign Up for Daily Headlines

Sign up to receive a daily email of today's top military news stories from Stars and Stripes and top news outlets from around the world.

Sign Up Now