Pope Leo XIV blesses faithful as he starts his weekly general audience in St. Peter’s Square, at the Vatican, on April 8, 2026.

Pope Leo XIV blesses faithful as he starts his weekly general audience in St. Peter’s Square, at the Vatican, on April 8, 2026. (Gregorio Borgia/AP)

ARTHUR I. CYR

ABOUT THE AUTHOR: Arthur I. Cyr is the author of “After the Cold War — American Foreign Policy, Europe and Asia.”

“An eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth …,” (Exodus 21:24) is a useful starting place for understanding the influence and leadership of Pope Leo XIV, the first American-born leader of the Roman Catholic Church, and challenges facing him. Leo just completed a highly visible, undeniably successful visit to France.

Large enthusiastic crowds greeted Pope Leo as he traveled through that country. France, described by media as a “secular” nation, demonstrated nonetheless that religious engagement, at least in terms of human longing and emotional searching, is present and represented in the large numbers of average citizens who assembled along the routes traveled.

France, like the United States, is formally a secular nation. The bloody French Revolution against their monarchy began in 1789, just 13 years after the 13 American colonies declared independence from rule by Great Britain. In France and the United States, church/state separation is codified in law.

But while representative government and the rule of law became quickly and firmly established in the new United States, France following their revolution oscillated radically among democracy, dictatorship and feeble monarchy. Under Napoleon Bonaparte, France became over many years the principal military aggressor in Europe.

Warfare became a way of life. In that sense, there was a return to ancient times.

To modern readers, the Old Testament passage above seems brutal, yet the sentiment expressed actually represented extraordinary progress.

Ancient warfare involved unrestrained killing, pillaging and destruction. By contrast, this Jewish law codified proportionality and limits. Historically and currently, the Vatican plays an important role in mitigating conflict, building on this fundamental insight.

Tolerance is a key to limiting conflict. Leo’s immediate predecessor Pope Francis made an important statement on tolerance of same-sex couples. His message is in the documentary “Francesco,” released in 2020 in Rome. Francis did not change formal Catholic doctrine but was dramatically demonstrating the importance of compassion.

Pope Francis’ April 2016 letter on marriage and the family should be viewed in this context. Media commentary emphasized Rome’s reiteration of commitment to traditional marriage, which is hardly news. The letter emphasizes tolerance for those who do not accept Catholic doctrine. That marks a change, important and widely overlooked.

The fundamental Christian message emphasizes compassion, and the Catholic Church over centuries has played a vital role in relief of poverty and human misery, and in promotion of human rights. The cumulative positive impact has been profound among the estimated 1.4 billion Roman Catholics alive today, and far beyond.

In 2015, Francis celebrated a Catholic mass in Revolution Square in Havana. Vatican efforts encouraging Cuba change reinforce more direct economic pressures.

During the Cold War, Pope John Paul II provided historic leadership in foreign policy. He supported Solidarity, the successful trade union-based reform movement in his native Poland. That in turn contributed to the fall of the Soviet Union and satellite states.

Horrific world wars of the past century reconfirm Catholic Church emphasis on restraint in war. War is still occurring, but global total war mercifully has been avoided.

Leo’s itinerary included visiting Metz to honor Robert Schuman, a key figure in European integration efforts. The European Union includes broad collaboration that not only discourages war but reinforces the defensive NATO alliance. Effective communication, logistics, supply and training benefit. Army Gen. Alexander Haig was particularly successful in this dimension as NATO Supreme Allied Commander Europe from 1974 to 1979.

Global human populations since World War II have experienced extraordinary positive developments. Masses of humanity are moving into relative comfort. Democracy is spreading.

Believers in earlier eras would regard this as miraculous.

Incentives for Pope Leo to visit France were positive, including a surging increase in Catholic baptisms.