(EDITOR’S NOTE: These are the letters that appeared in each edition of Stripes on this publication date. Click here to jump ahead to the Pacific edition letters)
European and Mideast editions
Possible for gays to changeI have read several letters [in Stars and Stripes] dealing with homosexuality. To me, many of those letters implied that homosexuality is normal.
From a biological perspective — I have a bachelor’s degree in biology — homosexuality is biologically illogical. Among vertebrates, male meets female, they mate and produce offspring, and so the species continue. Among humans, man meets woman, they fall in love, marry and produce children. Homosexual behavior, by its definition, cannot produce offspring.
James Dobson, host of the "Focus on the Family" radio show, once interviewed a psychiatrist who counseled homosexual men trying to escape from homosexuality. The psychiatrist said that behind every homosexual man he counseled was a sensitive boy whose father had been either physically or emotionally absent. Without a father to love and affirm him, such a boy could grow up to become a homosexual.
Last year on "60 Minutes," a correspondent interviewed a lesbian couple who had become parents through artificial insemination. One of the lesbians stated that she had grown up without a father. Therefore, without a positive male role model while growing up, a woman could become a homosexual.
But it is possible for homosexuals to change their sexual orientation. Stanton Jones, chairman of the Psychology Department at Wheaton College, said, "Anyone who says there is no hope [for change] is either ignorant or a liar. Every secular study of change has shown some success rate, and persons who testify to substantial healings by God are legion." Or, as Jesus said in Matthew’s gospel, "Come to me all you who are weary and burdened, and I will give you rest … and you will find rest for your souls."
Sgt. 1st Class Mark J. ScannellCamp Slayer, Iraq
A failure in leadershipI have heard some rather appalling things come from the most unlikely of sources. In an attempt to keep other senior leadership from making the same mistakes, I have comprised a small list of things they should never tell their soldiers.
The first should go without saying, but like every other thing in the Army, if it has to be briefed, it must have been done. Sergeants major and above should never tell their soldiers, "While I’m escorting you to your location, I hope it is one of your Humvees that gets hit, and not one of my MRAPs (mine resistant ambush protected vehicles)."
Another is, "We’re going to get you out of here as fast as possible with only the bare necessities. You can get the rest of your equipment at your new FOB (forward operating base)."
I recently read the article "A Failure in Generalship" (in the Armed Forces Journal). After reading and rereading this, I believe that Operation Iraqi Freedom V should be subtitled "A failure in leadership."
Sgt. Criss DoughertyForward Operating Base Delta, Iraq
New energy policy neededIt’s not surprising to hear both presidential candidates lobbying for new drilling for oilfields. That has been the rhetoric used over the years to allow for more drilling in more areas.
The question is whether we are naive enough [to] buy into [it]. We should have learned by now that the amount of oil available to be pumped out of the ground has little impact on the market.
Supply and demand drives prices, and supply is solely based on refinery capacity and output. Imagine an oil tycoon with his hands on the valve to refinery production. Cranking open the production reduces the overall price of oil and subsequently cuts profits. Cranking down on production increases overall prices, increases profit, prolongs supply, and even opens up new markets for drilling, thereby ensuring future health of the business.
"What is our alternative?" you might scream out. And you would be right, except that we can’t trust big oil with more oil supplies, and there are alternatives. The most promising one is making ethanol and methanol from things we can grow.
"Can’t be done!" the pundits say. Well, this is how oil was created in the first place.
"Using food crops for fuel has increased food prices!" the pundits say.
Poppycock. As we continue to pay farmers subsidies to not grow food crops. America has a vast capability to grow anything and everything, and to engineer crops to grow more, faster and more bountiful. We need a candidate with a new, viable energy policy for renewable energy, not the rhetoric of the past for more oil drilling.
Lt. Col. Scott F. WalterKandahar Airfield, Afghanistan
Another solution to shortageIn "Army faces shortage of majors" (article, Aug. 18), I noted that one current solution is to promote captains earlier to fill the shortage among majors. An additional solution to fill the shortfall is to delay promotion to lieutenant colonel. I recommend we start with Year Group 95 officers.
Maj. Parker Frawley (YG 94)Baghdad
Russia’s ‘tit-for-tat’ with WestRegarding "Cooling relations" (article, Aug. 27): Abkhazia and South Ossetia have been recognized by Russia. The seeds of this were planted when the West tragically allowed Kosovo to split from Serbia, which I thought was a very bad idea.
Russia has met the West tit-for-tat. We need to recognize that and move on. If the West continues to press for unification of Georgia with South Ossetia and Abkhazia, we will be playing into the Russians’ hands and providing them even more excuses to ramp up the rhetoric.
We warned Georgia not to do anything, and they ignored our warnings; this is an expensive lesson for them. Apparently the citizens of Abkhazia and South Ossetia are happy with the current situation, so I say let [it] stand.
Eric JiranCamp LeMonier, Djibouti
Freedom of and from religionI wish to rebut "Founding Fathers’ intention" (letter, Aug. 6).
The first thing I wish to mention are the letter writer’s statements about "separation of church and state" and how it is not guaranteed in the Constitution.
I would like to ask how can you prevent the establishment of a national religion, as he mentions, without the separation of church and state? Forcing someone or pressuring them to pray to your god is the establishment of a national religion.
I should think that freedom of religion and freedom from religion principles are one in the same.
Should not agnostics, atheists and people of other religions be given the same freedom from Christianity that the Founding Fathers sought from "popery" and the Anglican Church?
As to our "Christian nation," we have grown in our history from a nation of a religion to a nation of all religions, for believers and nonbelievers alike.
Our nation was intended to be a beacon of light for the whole world, not just a portion of it. Our nation is guided by principles that, whether God is mentioned everywhere or not at all, are always true.
I just thank God every day that I live in a nation where I have the freedom to worship him on my terms and not the terms of others.
Sgt. James AtwellCamp Virginia, Kuwait
Not ready to commit to GeorgiaThank you for running the opinions including those of Mikhail Gorbachev and others to help us see both sides of the current conflict in Georgia ("Georgia’s attack can’t be justified — or supported," Opinion, Aug. 14).
This conflict brings into question Georgia’s status as a future NATO member. The issue at the heart of this matter is whether we want to pledge the lives of our U.S. military in the name of Georgia. By answering that question, you will discover how you stand on the issue.
The famous John F. Kennedy line "Ich bin ein Berliner" ("I am a Berliner") made this point crystal clear in 1963. Our military was prepared to stand up for, and die with, the West Berliners at that moment.
Consider U.S. soldiers, sailors and airmen in 2008. With the number of NATO countries at an all-time high, "I am … a German, an Englishman, a Belgian, a Frenchman, a Turk, a Latvian, a Lithuanian, an Estonian …" and the list goes on, 26 times. Aggression against any of those countries automatically triggers the loss of American lives in a response. Do we really want to add to the list?
When you consider Defense Secretary Robert Gates’ statement recently that he cautioned the Georgians on Aug. 7 and 8 against starting, or getting tricked into starting, a conflict with Russia, I think I have my answer.
We must find other ways to promote world democracy. Are we ready to pledge American lives to the Georgians? It would be a pointed question to ask German President Angela Merkel and Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice before they commit any further. Anyone at Stars and Stripes up for asking it?
Christopher HayesJoint Base Balad, Iraq
Not paid what they’re worthI am responding to "Stop-loss bonus needed" (letter, Aug. 14).
The letter writer states that soldiers who have served honorably and choose not to continue service in the military should not be penalized. In the very next paragraph, the letter writer states that a $1,500-a-month bonus for stop-loss soldiers is too much and that the current $500 incentive we receive is more feasible. This is obviously a contradictory statement.
Soldiers who fall under stop-loss should be given more than just $500 in compensation. Their civilian jobs could’ve paid 30 percent more than what they were making in the military. So they could be losing, regardless of the incentives out here. One thing I do agree on is this: We make far less than what we are all worth. And if the military cared about its "expendables," it should at least show it.
I am a noncommissioned officer and take great offense when someone tries to paraphrase the creed but does not know it. The NCO Creed is a code that all NCOs should live by if they really care about their soldiers, and not just remember to pass a board.
The section of the NCO Creed to which the letter writer referred is "… accomplishment of my mission and the welfare of my soldiers." The mission? There are so many of them. The soldiers? Not all of them are under your control.
Staff Sgt. Richard RolosonCamp Taji, Iraq
Packaging may be to blameReading the back-and-forth arguments about postal theft, I have to admit I have listened to quite a few people lay blame before thinking of other possibilities when it comes to their beloved packages from home.
I want to believe that everyone handling my mail is honest; I learned a few months ago that I cannot even trust the box and pack [service] my husband uses back home. I was sent a package that was intended for an Air Force captain and the clerk who knows me there slapped my address on his box. He did not change the customs form; that is how I was able to contact the sender and forward the contents.
Just remember, [the problem] isn’t always the FPO or the APO; it could be poor packaging from the sender. We all love our mail, but we also need those who deliver, sort and send it. They should be thanked for all their hard work.
Petty Officer 2nd Class Melanie RobertsCamp Al Asad, Iraq
Soldiers decide what to eatI am writing in response to the "DFAC offerings can improve" (letter, Aug. 22).
The food served in the dining facility here beats Meals, Ready to Eat hands-down. During Operation Iraqi Freedom 1, we ate nothing but MREs and drank bottled water for the first three or four months. Every once in a while we would get a T-ration to eat. Now, with all the DFACs in Iraq, the offering is much better.
I work in the division DFAC on Camp Liberty [as a senior first cook]. We have fried foods, soda pop, desserts and all that bad stuff for soldiers. We also have a salad bar, sandwich bar, fresh-fruit bar and a fresh-made salad such as chicken caesar salad. We can only offer what our Class 1 substance has in the warehouses in Kuwait. The contractor, KBR, is simply fulfilling [its contract with] the Army.
There are choices to be made by the soldier [regarding] what he or she eats. Every day I see soldiers make the choice for fried food over healthy food. At our DFAC, we try to meet the needs of the soldiers, but we feed more than 2,500 soldiers a meal.
If I had my way I would go back to the way things were on my first tour and eat MREs instead of having to put up with the headaches that we in food service deal with each and every day. To quote my division command sergeant major from my last tour in 2005-2006: "This is the best DFAC that I have ever eaten in."
So, to the letter writer: See your senior food operations sergeant and get a case of MREs every four days till you redeploy home.
Staff Sgt. Michael HoodCamp Liberty, Iraq
Religion and the ConstitutionThe constitutional separation of church and state benefits theists and atheists alike from undue governmental influence. The neutrality of the government on such matters is absolutely essential in order to protect individual liberty.
Regrettably, there have been a few letters to the editor over the last several months that claim that since the words "separation of church and state" do not appear in the Constitution, [the principle] therefore does not exist. It’s strange that they never seem to notice that the words "unification of church and state" do not appear in the Constitution either.
The First Amendment states in part: "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof." Simply put, the state has nothing to do with the institution of religion or interfering with its practice. This pertains to all religions; none is given preferential treatment.
Here is the important part, as the reciprocal is implicit: Religion has nothing to do with the institution of government or interfering with its practice. If this is objected to, then consider that the only other time religion is mentioned in the Constitution, it is explicitly forbidden; Article VI affirms that "no religious Test shall ever be required as a Qualification to any Office or public Trust under the United States." If the founders wanted to mention any particular religion, or abolish it, they easily could have. Instead what we find is that the Constitution remains neutral.
Clearly, then, regardless of any spiritual beliefs the Founding Fathers may have held, they had the supreme wisdom to eliminate potentially divisive religious differences from the mechanisms of the government.
Capt. Brock PetersIraq
