European and Mideast editions(EDITOR’S NOTE: These are the letters that appeared in each edition of Stripes on this publication date. Click here to jump ahead to the Pacific edition letters)
Who but AFN …Who but American Forces Network would show no-name games while there is a No. 1-seeded team (Kansas versus Kentucky) playing at the same time [in the National Collegiate Athletic Association men’s basketball tournament]?
Who but AFN would bounce between multiple games and still fail to display that No. 1-seeded team’s game?
Who but AFN would show more public-service announcements than actual game time (or switch to another game during breaks in the current game)?
Who but AFN would finish the current game and go to “SportsCenter” — which gets more than its fair share of airtime on this network — rather than switching to the remaining seven minutes of that No. 1-seeded team’s game?
Who but NCAA tournament fans deployed on the other side of the globe would stay up into the early hours of the morning to see games that AFN didn’t bother to show?
First Lt. Richard SullivanAli Al Salem, Kuwait
When did ‘welfare’ begin?The article “8 unauthorized caregivers found on base” (March 13), about nannies working for families in military housing in Heidelberg, Germany, has left me pondering when did warfare end and welfare begin?
Here were soldiers and dependents who put other soldiers, dependents and military employees at considerable risk, abetted the stealing of personal property, violated German government laws as well as U.S. Army security regulations, and the command response is, that’s a no-no?
In this era of political correctness, where everyone is a victim and not held responsible for his actions, has “what’s in it for me” and “what can I get away with” become the norm?
Chief Warrant Officer 4 Dennis Carroll (retired)Ziegelhausen, Germany
‘Rantings’ need a disclaimerI’ve seen several letters about why Ann Coulter’s column should remain in this newspaper. I read her March 19 opinion piece (“Walter Reed victim of a civil disservice”), about all the failures at Walter Reed Army Medical Center, which she blames on the Democratic Party and the civil service system.
According to a March 11 article in The Washington Post, “The scandal over treatment of outpatients at Walter Reed Army Medical Center has focused attention on the Army’s decision to privatize the facilities support workforce at the hospital, a move commanders say left the building maintenance staff undermanned. Some Democratic lawmakers have questioned the decision to hire IAP Worldwide Services, a contractor with connections to the Bush administration and to KBR, a Halliburton subsidiary.”
This administration has been in office for more than six years and it amazes me how some people still blame Bill Clinton or the Democratic Party for all the country’s problems.
If Coulter’s column is going to continue in Stripes, maybe the editor should put a disclaimer on her rantings to state that this is entirely her very biased opinion and not necessarily based on facts. Either that, or move her articles to the comic section.
Bob CarperMannheim, Germany
Coulter shows her bigotrySeveral readers have written against removing Ann Coulter’s column from Stars and Stripes, arguing that doing so would violate the First Amendment and her right to free speech. These readers display a misunderstanding of the Constitution they have sworn to defend.
If our government jailed Coulter for her remarks, fined her, harassed her family or compelled Amazon.com to stop selling her books, free-speech advocates would have reason to complain. All of these are examples of censorship, which we must vigorously resist. We should never allow our government to prevent a citizen from saying something, no matter how outlandish.
However, none of these things has happened. What has happened is that certain privately owned newspapers have decided that Coulter’s column is no longer for them. This is their right. In fact, it would be a bizarre and gross violation of freedom of the press if it were forced to continue to run her column.
Stripes readers should be exposed to the broadest variety of opinion. To present the same old views each week would be a disservice. By all means, give us liberal columnists who criticize Condoleezza Rice’s failed Middle East diplomacy, and give us conservative columnists who criticize Joe Lieberman’s vote against banning same-sex marriage. But the moment a columnist applies a racial slur to Rice, or an anti-Semitic insult to Lieberman, that writer stops arguing rationally and enters the territory of bigotry. It is also the same moment that writer would be looking for a new job. Coulter has loudly staked a claim in this territory and is mature enough to deal with the consequences.
Drop her column. Doing so is not censorship. It is the day-to-day administration of a newspaper that purports to be taken seriously.
Lt. Cmdr. George DolanCamp Speicher, Iraq
A limit to liberals’ ‘tolerance’I’m writing in response to “Won’t sit down for stand-up” (letter, March 19), where yet another “proud liberal” urges Stars and Stripes to censor Ann Coulter’s column by having it removed.
The letter writer claimed there are certain constants in life: death, taxes and when Coulter isn’t getting enough publicity she denigrates and ridicules those on the left. Well, I have one to add to the list myself: liberals’ intolerance of anyone who doesn’t think just like them. I thought being a liberal meant being tolerant of other people and thought. I guess liberals’ “tolerance” only extends to those who think exactly like they do.
The writer asked that Stripes replace Coulter with another “good, responsible conservative columnist.” Would that columnist be “good” and “responsible” like Arianna Huffington? That’s truly laughable. Huffington is one of the most outrageous and absurd columnists on the left who has made equally offensive comments about President Bush and anyone on the right. Where are the writer’s calls for Huffington’s column to be removed? I guess we’re back to the intolerance issue.
It’s real simple. If you don’t like a person’s column, don’t read it. You don’t try to censor another person’s First Amendment right because you don’t agree with their viewpoint.
Petty Officer 3rd Class Mike JonesCamp Patriot, Kuwait
Irish are forgottenMarch has been proclaimed Irish Heritage Month by President Bush.
March has been proclaimed Irish Heritage Month at least since the first President Bush and was designated in 1995 during President Clinton’s tenure by Congress in Public Law 103-379, but never gets any press or coverage by American Forces Network or popular press.
Everyone seems to think we should celebrate our heritage only on St. Patrick’s Day when everyone’s “Irish,” but we should be celebrating the contributions of our forefathers the whole month, if not all year. St. Patrick’s Day seems to be the day to drink green beer and doesn’t touch on what the Irish have done. [Many of the] presidents of our great nation can claim Irish heritage, and we have contributed greatly in the public sector — from military, firefighters and policemen to presidents and senators.
We should not take away from the other observances this month, such as Women’s History Month, as [those groups] have made great contributions to our country as well and are equally important in making our nation great. However, I feel our contributions are forgotten, and the stories of our struggles have been pushed aside.
Matt OrcuttKaiserslautern, Germany
Pacific editionToo much on Army’s plateThe Army has too much going on to move so many soldiers back to the U.S.
President Bush wants an additional 20,000-plus troops on the ground [in Iraq] along with an additional 2,200 military policemen, and the standing up of Africa Command. Doesn’t it seem like we are trying to do too much?
I would like to offer a little armchair quarterbacking. Starting with this new command, I can’t think of one country in Africa that will be able to host anything more than a tent city, considering force protection and infrastructure concerns. How about building the soldier piece from forces already in the theater? Leave the families in Germany at the installations slated for closure, deploy the soldiers for three- to six-month stints. This way we make good on our commitment to families. If there is a family emergency, the soldier doesn’t have to travel all the way to the U.S.
I also think we have lost track of who is on first and who is on second, with all this deploying and redeploying. Halt all deactivations until we have the full accounting, manpower and infrastructure to support transformation.
A lot of soldiers will hate me, but is there an air defense threat? Do we need that many soldiers to run a signal command? The fine print in everyone’s contract does state they will work in their military occupational specialty unless the needs of the Army dictate differently. Armywide, they can surely scare up 20,000 or so soldiers who don’t have a patch on their right shoulder.
I am coming up on 10 years as a retired soldier and would probably be dead weight in combat, but I sure would like to see us come out on top of this thing and do the right thing by our soldiers and families.
Larry C. BostickHanau, Germany
Mistaken ‘take’ on Iraq warIn “Crimes under the UCMJ” (letter, Feb. 2), the first lieutenant wrote: “Now the left’s biggest ‘claim’ is that the war in Iraq is illegal, yet the legality has been proved many times over. So that argument falls through.”
He did not quote or show evidence of the “proof.” If he was relying on the strength of the resolution passed by Congress giving the president the authority to go to war if or when he saw fit, then the letter writer has been brainwashed right along with the multitudes. Congress cannot give the president power to do anything.
Being commander in chief does not give the president the authority to order the armed forces to attack/invade another country. All wars/conflicts on foreign soil by U.S. troops since the end of World War II have been illegal. All wars are about money, power and killing people.
I salute the first lieutenant for his service in our military, but not on his take on the Iraq war.
Frank VaughnLakeview, Ore.
Consult ‘designer’s manual’A few questions asked in “Errors in intelligent design” (letter, March 16) need to be addressed.
Eating, drinking and breathing from the same hole? That’s called design efficiency. There’s even a backup for breathing called a nose. Specifically, we’re made in the image of the creator: God. [To the writer:] Please consult the designer/creator manual for further instruction. It’s called the Bible. Caution: A lack of understanding doesn’t disprove the Bible. It just proves, well, a lack of understanding.
As to choking and drowning hazards, welcome to mortality. [There are] lots of ways to die. Come to think of it, why isn’t my skin bulletproof? A design flaw, no doubt.
Bad knees, bad back? The design is fine, it’s the maintenance programs of the created that are often nonexistent. Does a car change its own oil? Abuse your body, deal with the consequences. What about the struggle for survival and evil in the world? Please consult the designer’s manual. Your answers are all there. Ditto for the questions on “why death?”
God designed everything and gave man free choice. The results of these choices show across the breadth and width of his creation. Perfection of design was rejected in the Garden of Eden by the created. As such, we now live in a world of our own making. What we have now isn’t what God wanted for us, it’s what we chose for ourselves.
So don’t blame the designer. He offers a great warranty plan through his son, Jesus. Please see the designer’s manual for further details.
Patrick WyettCamp Arifjan, Kuwait
Give AAFES some competitionAfter a recent trip to the post exchange, I decided it was time to offer my ideas to the rest of the military community that uses PX services.
The Army and Air Force Exchange Service has long touted the huge benefit that it provides to soldiers and family members. As one takes a closer look, the actual benefit is quite small.
We live in a capitalistic society. This translates into competition among providers of goods and services, which, in turn, causes prices to fall. This is the basis of our economy. This, however, does not exist in the AAFES world. There is no competition on post. All businesses are run by AAFES. If a new business wants to open on post (a daunting task, at best) it must agree to be run by AAFES. Prices, employees, goods, services — all AAFES. This does not bode well for the military consumer.
At a stateside assignment, this problem is easily resolved by traveling usually just a mile or two off post to the large variety of discount stores that offer prices much cheaper than any AAFES establishment. For those overseas, we are forced to use on-post facilities and pay prices far higher than your local Wal-Mart.
One can order online and save a lot, if he is able to find a supplier that will ship to an Army post office box. This process, however, is long and time-consuming.
The time has come [to bring some] competition to the AAFES monopoly. Only when other establishments not run by AAFES are allowed to operate on post will we enjoy the benefits of capitalism.
Hmm … I wonder if Wal-Mart will read this?
Spc. Christopher M. MeyeringVilseck, Germany
Stop ‘trash programming’It has been a very disappointing season in programming management of American Forces Network scheduling that we depend upon get us through our stressful day.
They either start the wrong program, start too late or broadcast week-old episodes, if not older. We expect a day or so delay, but to just dump regular programs for junk reruns is traumatic. AFN needs to get with the program and give the armed forces a near-real-time entertainment show and not waste our time.
My wife and I live for the Jay Leno and David Letterman monologues to calm our stressful day, but AFN finds a way to mess that up and delivers us rerun trash programming.
Kerry GellertRamstein Air Base, Germany
