European and Mideast editions(EDITOR’S NOTE: These are the letters that appeared in each edition of Stripes on this publication date. Click here to jump ahead to the Pacific edition letters)
Push-up punishment ‘folly’I read “Push-up controversy led to Heidelberg coach’s removal” (article, Feb. 21, European edition) with consternation. If Coach Brad Shahan was removed solely because of the number of push-ups he required of an extracurricular team (200 in two hours), which most coaches would not find excessive, and Department of Defense Dependents Schools condemns this as corporal punishment, what number constitutes too many?
Joining a school sports team, as well as accepting the discipline dispensed thereof, is voluntary. The presented argument is so weak and the punitive action against Shahan such folly, where is “the rest of the story” justifying it? Should I, a physical education teacher, be wary of the next time I challenge students to physically exert themselves?
Perhaps we as educators should retreat from the fray and permit the inmates run of the asylum. Is this the beginning of the end of DODDS sports?
Marguerite LeavittStuttgart, Germany
Conditioning is part of sportHaving coached high school football in the States, I find the action by Department of Defense Dependents Schools an overreaction to a disciplined and successful football program (“Push-up controversy led to Heidelberg coach’s removal”).
Young men have to train hard to play a competitive sport. Players also have to listen to the coach to have success. If parents and their boys are not willing to achieve discipline and conditioning, then they should not be in a competitive sport such as football.
Football is a hard, rough sport at the high school level. I have seen high school freshmen football practices that are more extreme than the one described in your article. Take the same practice and run it in the heat of August anywhere in the States, it’s just an average part of two-a-day practices.
This attitude by DODDS, some parents and their children may be why a lot of college recruiters are not beating down the doors for DODDS football players. I have seen more recruiters at a small AA school in the States.
David CardonaHeidelberg, Germany
Don’t attack military brethrenI have four words for the writer of “Air Force has it easy” (letter, Feb. 23): One Team, One Fight.
It is important that we should recognize the team that fights in this war instead of taking shots at it. That job belongs to the media and al-Qaida.
Most of our airmen work and live in the same conditions as our Army and Marine Corps brethren. Their job is no less important than the rest of the joint force. In fact, quite a few young airmen are dying right now as they drive the letter writer’s convoys across the landscape. Are they any less committed to victory? Is their sacrifice any less significant?
The length of a deployment does not begin to quantify service. I spent last winter with the Marines in Fallujah, Iraq. My quarters consisted of a moldy mattress in a toolshed with no door or working heat. I did not complain. Nor have I voiced complaint over the 300 days per year I spent deployed during the 1990s. Is there a reason for me to complain about the 40 consecutive months I have flown combat missions in Iraq and Afghanistan? I may not get deployment credit for those sorties, but it doesn’t mean I wasn’t there, or any less committed to the job.
Please be careful when making attacks on the Air Force. Those types of comments only serve to help the enemy.
Maj. T. Mark McCurleyDeployed
Give us ‘some real balance’We hear so much about fairness and balance (“Advocate gives readers an outlet to shape Stripes,” Ombudsman, Reid MacCluggage, Feb. 13), but rarely see it actually occur.
As others have commented here, I find it increasingly difficult to pick up a copy of Stars and Stripes. Don’t get me wrong, I don’t want page after page of sunshine pumping. I do expect some manner of balance of reporting that appeals not only to the tinfoil hat-wearing George Soros zombie, but to someone who wants to read a fair article, such as myself. Count the number of articles that come from the New York Times, Los Angeles Times and other well-known far-left-leaning newspapers. Compare that to articles derived from centrist-right outlets.
This far-leftward turn of our (armed forces family) media has even infiltrated American Forces Network radio broadcasts. These folks brag on the air of “political discussion that covers the political spectrum” during their morning “NewsWatch” segment. What do we get? Some cowboy hat-wearing dope (Jim Hightower), followed by left-leaning commentaries by Charles Osgood and Katie Couric.
Where’s the balance? If AFN is going to broadcast a blithering loon like Hightower, why not provide equal air time for someone from the right immediately afterward?
Providing 40 minutes of Rush Limbaugh does not make AFN balanced; not when you compare those 40 minutes of air time to the daily inundation of National Public Radio, Ed Schultz, Hightower and the like.
Give us a break, and give us listeners and readers some real balance.
Glenn NewtonNaples, Italy
Pacific Editions
Draft logic doesn’t hold upIn the Feb. 8 letter “Liberals couldn’t handle draft,” the writer states that it would be the “liberals” who would dodge or buy their way out of service to their country.
It is exactly this kind of talk that created such a rift in our government. People get so blindly devoted to their party, they start lumping people together under vague definitions. I mean, the writer’s devotion to his country is inspiring, but his devotion to the Republican Party has blinded him (and many others) from the hypocrisy in their statements when it comes to their judgment of the “liberals.”
The writer stated that it would be the liberals who would avoid service, “buy their way out of it,” if you will. Gosh, avoiding true military service to our country? That sounds an awful lot like our current president. Sure, Bush was in the Air National Guard, but he even flaked out of that (with no repercussions). If the letter writer wants to judge someone based purely on their service to their country through military service, it seems our commander in chief should not be one of his favorites.
John Kerry, no matter what his other flaws are, should be held in very high esteem; he at least served in the military and in a combat zone. He’s about as liberal as you can get and still be in mainstream politics.
Going into the even less obvious, a recent survey by the New York Times showed that fewer than 40 percent of current Republican senators and representatives served in any form of the U.S. military. Even fewer served in a combat zone; despite that they are all in the right age range to have served in Vietnam.
As far as liberals avoiding service to their country, I couldn’t agree less. I am a liberal serving as an active-duty Marine. My grandfather was a decorated Marine in Korea. He was a liberal. I find myself meeting many Marines who, despite liberal views, still joined the military out of a sense of duty to their country, not their political party.
I ask anyone with the same point of view as the writer: If your view of politicians or a political party is based so much on their military service to their country, why did you vote for George W. Bush?
Lance Cpl. William GriffithCamp Foster, Okinawa
Honor codes not the problemI am not attempting to legitimize the points of Dan Thomasson’s Feb. 21 column (“Academy’s honor code is an unrealistic standard”) by making a coherent argument against his, but I can’t stand to see the honor codes of the service academies defamed in such a tactless manner.
Thomasson is actually correct, though. The honor code is an unrealistic standard. For those who do lie, cheat or steal regularly and do so without conscience, I can understand that these basic tenets that should guide any society must be nearly impossible to meet. Because, of course, we are “like any normal, mostly still teenage student body.”
The cases of honor violations that are heavily scrutinized in the media do not represent the kind of students we have joining our military academies. As a student belonging to this “prisonlike” environment, I knew perfectly well that attending the Naval Academy wasn’t so I could give in to my “raging hormones” and inclination toward “sexual escapades or drunkenness now and then.” This is the behavior that Thomasson indirectly condones by refusing to believe that these plain standards should be maintained for people our age.
The honor code is not a result of lazy adults. It does not serve as a babysitter. In all that we do, there is an underlying principle of being responsible for our actions — which, believe it or not, is probably a better option than letting students give in to their mere “nature.”
Thomasson says pornography, alcohol abuse and high rates of failure are characteristic of a normal teenage student body. He says that the expectation to not lie, cheat or steal is an unrealistic standard. He also says young students should be monitored and not held to standards of accountability. Well then I must be “silly and naive,” if I have faith in a future guided by his wisdom.
Chelsea RicketsonAnnapolis, Md.
Judge Romney on own meritI must say that I was dismayed with a headline in your Feb. 28 edition. It read “Romney’s presidential bid brings polygamous forefathers to light.”
I really dislike dishonesty in an article title, and this one has it in total. It’s not [Mitt Romney’s] running [for president] that is bringing his forefathers to the light; it is the media. The very writers of the article are doing what they claim his run is doing, and that is despicable.
Neither he nor anyone else should be held responsible for the actions of the father (or mother) — nor should they be given respect for actions done by their parents. Give it a rest. Mr. Romney is not a polygamist. End of story.
Lt. Cmdr. Steven SpeightNaha Military Port, Okinawa
