European and Mideast editions(EDITOR’S NOTE: These are the letters that appeared in each edition of Stripes on this publication date. Click here to jump ahead to the Pacific edition letters)
Wake up to Arab threatIn response to the letters “Don’t print hate letters,” (Aug. 8) and “Giving Muslims a bad name” (Aug. 10): Wake up and smell the jihad. Apparently the writers have not been paying attention the last couple of decades. These people hate us (unless you don’t remember the celebrating in the streets when 3,000 Americans died on Sept. 11).
Yes, you are right, not all Arabs are grooming their children to be suicide bombers, but a good chunk are. Let’s take the Palestinians. If they were so concerned about their children’s future they would not have elected a terrorist organization to govern them. (Yes, Hamas is a terrorist organization, no matter what France says.) And now the unwavering support throughout the Arab world for Hezbollah (also a terrorist organization) makes it all the more evident that Arabs want bloodshed, not peace.
If these people wanted a future for their children they would be teaching them ethnic tolerance, not marching them through the streets of Tehran chanting “death to Israel, death to America.”
Maybe some day we can all wake up and realize the truth.
Cpl. Adam AllenKuwait
Improving Muslims’ imageThe writer of the letter “Giving Muslims a bad name” (Aug. 10) — who says he was raised in a Muslim country — seems to be mistaken in his response to the [Aug. 3] letter “Arabs sacrifice children.” Having not read the previous letter, I guess perhaps it might have been a bit narrow-minded, but that kind of speech is not what is giving good Muslims a bad name.
What is actually giving good Muslims a bad name are bad Muslims. If the letter writer would take a look at the conflicts around the world he would find a common denominator: Muslims. The Philippines, Africa, Indonesia, the Middle East and the West, all are dealing with Muslim violence. It’s situations such as the [Prophet Muhammad] cartoon incident that make people question Muslim peacefulness.
During a Religion of Peace demonstration in England in February, peaceful Muslims held up signs that read, “Freedom go to Hell,” “Behead those who insult Islam,” and “Exterminate those who slander Islam.” I found it ironic that on the day “Giving Muslims a bad name” ran, about 18 people of mostly Pakistani heritage were taken into custody for wanting to blow up trans-Atlantic flights.
The writer is enjoying his freedom of speech, which in many Muslim countries is not possible. Perhaps if more Muslims spoke out against violence, perceptions would change.
Lisa SanchezStuttgart, Germany
The meaning of ‘lift fire’During mobilization training at Camp Shelby, Miss., we participated in infantry lanes training. Very basic, very important, and a good review for most of the soldiers in our battalion. During an after-action review from a simulated assault, a cadre sergeant first class asked, “Before we get started, who was that idiot who kept firing after the command to ‘lift fire’?” I raised my hand and said, “I raised the muzzle of my weapon to shoot over the heads of our friendly attackers, but wanted the enemy to think they were still being fired on by our squad.”
The SFC then stated: “All the Army schools I’ve been to teach that ‘lift fire’ means ‘cease fire.’” I asked, “Then why wasn’t the command ‘cease fire’ given?” The SFC responded he didn’t have time to argue but would speak to my command if I persisted.
I have since questioned six seasoned noncommissioned officers and officers about the meaning of “lift fire” and gotten six slightly different answers, including one who agreed with the Shelby SFC that it means “stop shooting.” I also searched through written operating procedures, field manuals and training procedures, all of which tend to back my contention that “lift fire” means continue firing only in a different (usually predetermined) direction. It is almost synonymous with “shift fire,” which sounds very similar in the heat of battle.
The point I am trying to make is that the entire Army should have the same understanding of the commands “lift fire,” “shift fire” and “cease fire.”
Staff Sgt. K.T. “Red” GrahamCamp Buehring, Kuwait
Don’t whine about dutyWhen I read letters or congressional complaints from soldiers, spouses and family members, it saddens me to think that some have nothing more to do than make what I see as frivolous complaints. I read about not having a baseball field in a deployed war zone, having to work long hours, the price of Army and Air Force Exchange Service goods.
Let me share my experience: I now have 15 years of military service, and plan to continue until I “get tired,” not retire. One week after I married, I entered the military. I sent my wife a letter with instructions on getting her ID card, vehicle registration and any other military documents she needed. With four deployments and countless field training exercises lasting 30 days or more, not once have I encouraged or allowed a family member to write a complaint in my behalf. This was “our” decision to join the military.
The nature of the job and assignment causes us to work long and unconventional hours. My family understands and supports it fully. Tell me: Has anyone ever written a congressional complaint about all of those three- and four-day weekends we get? What about when the workload is light and we are released early? Family time and organizational events? I don’t think I ever saw one complaining when unit time and funding is used for intramural sports and recreational activities, or when AAFES offers us no tax and deep discounts. And what about the wonderful holiday meals our dining halls provide?
Wise up, if you don’t like the hours, why did you join? Don’t go blaming your recruiter, either. You were grown when you accepted and signed. Spouses, this is the nature of our job. Get used to it, or get out. No one likes a whiner.
Sgt. 1st Class George HudsonAfghanistan
Lyrics study may be too lateIn response to the Aug. 8 Associated Press article on music lyrics (“Study says raunchy lyrics prompt teens to have sex,” Mideast edition; “Study suggesting raunchy lyrics are prompting teens to have sex,” European edition): Did it take a study to finally realize the influence today’s so-called music has on our teens. The powers of suggestion within the lyrics make for inevitable responses to some degree. The young people are already in search of identity and for an explanation to the curious urges in their bodies.
My problem is that this should have been identified long ago, and some measures taken to avoid where we are now. Then, the bottom line identifies itself. Money! We have become a people who will do anything and/or allow anything for the love of money, even if it includes the cost of our youth. We want the best for them, but we continue to surround them with commercialized trash that really identifies who we are. Free enterprise allows these activities, whether they break moral parameters or not, to run rampant in our society and the world we live in. If only we could have nipped this in the bud.
As it is, it may be too late. Study that.
Rev. (Capt.) Jeff SaffoldCamp Arifjan, Kuwait
Pacific editionRescue effort was complexRegarding Jim Maleka’s Aug. 7 column “Terrorism transcends political parties”: The failed Desert I (Operation Eagle Claw, April 24, 1980) rescue attempt of American hostages from Iran was the result of many factors, but not the military members involved. The logistical, tactical, communications interoperability — equipment shortfalls — was the main reason this mission was aborted. Not an “incompetent military unit,” as Makela states.
We had the best of the best on the ground, in the air and on the sea. The unit to which I was assigned during this time was being considered for a tasking to provide communications support.
As with all plans, things can and do go wrong, with unexpected results affecting mission accomplishment or continuation. Some factors here were teams of diverse members who normally did not work or train together at this time. This has since changed. The military units had incompatible doctrines and were put into service to operate in an unforgiving combat desert environment full of firsts. There were so many challenges to overcome, refueling of helicopters being one. The unanticipated variables to overcome were mounting as they executed the planned mission.
The mission was aborted due to lack of resources to extract the hostages and teammembers upon completion. It was during the aborted mission a helicopter struck a C-130 transport, causing an enormous explosion and killing eight servicemembers.
The Department of Defense has come a long way in joint service operations and is continually adapting … for increased mission success and warrior mind-set. These heroes blazed a path for us to follow and that path is used today in many doctrines of conflict, including Iraq and Afghanistan.
Tech. Sgt. David J. Moore (retired)Osan Air Base, South Korea
Article lacked meat of matterI am saddened that your report of the survey conducted in South Korea (“Poll cites appeal of dog soup,” article, Aug. 10, Korea edition; “Poll: 1 in 3 Korean dog owners eat dog soup,” Okinawa edition) failed to mention that the consumption of dog meat has been illegal in South Korea since 1981.
The report also asserts that consumption of dog is traditional in Korea. Those activists briefly mentioned in the report can and do show that it is not part of Korean traditional culture to abuse and torture animals, nor is dog consumption traditional, unless you count approximately 50 years of cruelty and 25 years of law-breaking as tradition. It is certainly illegal, as there are only two sources for the dog: illegal dog farms and stolen pets.
I’m not only saddened by the illegal trade in dog meat but also by your “coverage” of that illegal activity without a word to indicate its true nature.
Petty Officer 1st Class William J. McGruder (retired)Busan, South Korea
AAFES doesn’t go where you goThe other day I was looking in the Army and Air Force Exchange Service catalog and found a patio lounge chair that would be great for where I am at, not that there are any patios here. It was a little pricey but what the heck, I wanted it. So I tried to order it; it was on sale for $69.95.
Now, AAFES’ slogan is “We go where you go.” It is plastered on everything.
When I tried to order it, AAFES said it does not ship this item to an Army post office address. For an organization that says it goes where I go, this seems a little odd.
So, I did what any good shopper would do if a store cannot get me what I want. I went to walmart.com. Not only was the chair less money, $57 with shipping, but, believe it or not, it will ship it to an APO.
I checked my order today and the chair in question is en route as I write this letter. So, in the future, if I need a candy bar I will go to AAFES; anything more, I will go to Wal-Mart or wherever, get what I want, save money and get it sent to me.
Master Sgt. Craig TopelCamp Buehring, Kuwait
‘Noncommercial’ confusionI am confused about some recent “noncommercials” I have seen on American Forces Network television.
One expounds upon the evils of credit cards and how they can be addictive. They make credit card addiction comparable to drug and alcohol addiction.
Now I am seeing a commercial asking parents if they have purchased all of the needed supplies for the upcoming school year. Some of the items suggested are clothes, bikes and computers. I’m not sure if a bike is a good suggestion for a new school year purchase. Then, at the end of the noncommercial, viewers are encouraged to put those purchases on their Star Card. Last time I checked, the Star Card was a credit card that is still reported to credit agencies when defaults happen. Is it because the Army and Air Force Exchange Service has the ability to get its money back through pay garnishments that somehow this is not one of the problem-causing credit cards?
How can AFN show noncommercials about the evils of a thing, and then allow an agency such as AAFES to encourage the use of that evil. So far, I am just glad I haven’t seen the two noncommercials back to back. How hypocritical would that be?
Maybe it is just AFN supporting the monopolistic customer, noncaring AAFES. Who knows? I only ask that someone apply reason to what is shown on the television.
Sgt. Daniel PondHeidelberg, Germany
Be careful on linking symbolsThe ongoing discussion concerning various religious symbols has at times been humorous as some individuals demonstrate their limited knowledge on this topic. An example of this is Spc. Christopher Abbey’s assertion that the Chinese wàn (Japanese manji) and the swastika are the same “regardless of the direction” (“Symbols complicate markers,” letter, Aug. 8)
This last statement would seem to indicate he is aware the swastika is a mirror image of the Chinese character. It also should be noted that the German swastika was rotated 45 degrees for the Nazi symbol; ergo, they are not the same thing. Indeed, no Buddhist temple I have ever visited had a swastika; but they do have the wàn. (I have been living in and traveling around Asia for almost 22 years.)
And then there is the debate about the pentacle (also spelled pantacle). Many people seem to be confusing the term with the word pentagram. The earliest reference to pentacle includes the Seal of Solomon.
There are medieval Christian, Islamic and Jewish legends concerning the Seal of Solomon. One version has the design as a pentagram enclosed in a circle while another version has it as a hexagram enclosed in a circle. This later version is suggested to be the basis for the Star of David.
As a holy symbol, early Christians used the pentagram to represent the five wounds Jesus suffered during crucifixion. This practice was discontinued during the 4th century after Emperor Constantine launched a campaign against the pentagram, as it was also used in Roman mythology to represent the goddess Venus. This use predated the Christian era.
Now as for Wicca and the pentacle; this neo-pagan religion was established in the 1950s, which means that Israeli and gentile use of the pentacle predates the Wicca use by thousands of years. I know some claim it is based on pagan witchcraft; however, from my own studies, its philosophy seems to be more like yin and yang of Taoism.
Just for the record, I am neither Wiccan nor Taoist.
Senior Master Sgt. Allen E. Holecek (retired)Misawa, Japan
