European and Mideast editions(EDITOR’S NOTE: These are the letters that appeared in each edition of Stripes on this publication date. Click here to jump ahead to the Pacific edition letters)
Separating truth from trashThe publisher and editorial director of Stars and Stripes should be ashamed. The one paper we have daily access to decided to publish a front page story full of ridicule, conjecture and anonymous critical evaluations — supposedly in our ranks — about how subjectively pathetic we are as a combined fighting force (“Guard faces lessened combat role in Iraq,” May 9 European edition, “Role of National Guard in Iraq diminishing quickly,” May 9 Mideast edition). Just exactly how did you think the military community would react to this?
I don’t blame the Los Angeles Times writer. It’s blatantly obvious he had an agenda. The article reeks of entertainment for those who haven’t served a day in any branch or component of the military, reinforcing the idea that the only response we’re capable of to any question is “hoo-aah.”
You have cast doubt about your abilities to recognize the trash brought in by the writer from a major California newspaper and about the competencies of the Stars and Stripes staff. We count on you for just about everything newsworthy. This article was not.
If the creation of malcontent for those who serve in this theater or any other theater, regardless of military affiliation, within the ranks was the intent of the story — mission accomplished. I would respectfully request more input from the commander at Stripes regarding publishing this type of article. Sir, the damage is done.
I know Stripes will move on to the next issue, this letter serving only as fuel for discussion at the dining facility. In the meantime, the troops of all branches and all components and the armies of the various nationalities will volunteer and skillfully serve together to accomplish the goals of our president, Congress, and the American people who pay us. These are the facts.
Chief Warrant Officer 3 Alan ReedCamp Buehring, Kuwait
Criticism hides real failuresIn response to the writer of the bogus May 9 article about the National Guard: If it were the truth that the Guard is not properly trained or ready to perform combat missions, then why didn’t the writer mention the name of this mysterious leader who made this comment? Where are the facts that stand behind this statement?
Personally, I believe that this is just a way for senior military advisers at the Pentagon to steer away from their faulty war plans. I say this because it is not without question that we are stretched thin with this global war and the Department of Defense used the Guard to compensate for the shortages in the Reserve and active-duty components.
The real truth is that after Hurricane Katrina, the DOD realized how much it had screwed up by putting Guard units into deployments overseas. With the Guard deployed, who will respond to emergencies within the States? With the Guard deployed, look how long it took for relief and support to help with the aftermath of Katrina.
If you ask me, senior leaders making a statement that Guard units are not as ready as the Reserves and active components is just their way of walking away from the responsibility that they had screwed up. What about the Army values of integrity, loyalty and honesty? It appears that it only applies as long as you do not work within the Pentagon.
As an active-duty soldier, I can honestly say thank you to the Reserve and Guard components for their support and help on these long deployments in hell. We are all here not as components but as brothers and sisters in arms.
William LouderbackQ-West, Iraq
Source needs a refresherThere was wrong information in your May 9 story “Role of National Guard in Iraq diminishing quickly.” The article claims that Reserve soldiers only serve in support roles: “Reserve soldiers are exclusively assigned to support units, such as transportation companies or civil affairs teams.” Not true.
I am from a Reserve unit along with around 700 to 800 other soldiers. Many of us are currently serving as MiTTs ( military transition team advisers) all over Iraq. While some do advise support services, many of us are embedded in infantry divisions, brigades and battalions as advisers on the front lines of this war. We are the tip of the spear in standing up to the Iraqi army so American and coalition soldiers can return home.
We are not a Special Forces unit but we are doing a traditional Special Forces mission because there were not enough SF available at the moment due to the outstanding job they are doing in other areas. There are also numerous Individual Ready Reserve servicemembers from various branches of the armed services serving in combat roles.
There were other points in the article I would like to address but will stick to one topic at a time. It sounds as if your anonymous source needs to bone up on some more facts before throwing out quotes in the coffee shop. Please invite them to drop by and see the Reserve MiTTs. We will be at the front of the fight!
Maj. Mark ArringtonU.S. Army ReservesIraq
Stop bashing the GuardI read articles like the May 9 one bashing the National Guard and it makes me wonder what is wrong with these people that makes them write this kind of garbage. You would think Guardsmen came from some other training then the active-duty.
I was active-duty for eight years before stress cards, Internet cafés, weekend passes or whatever crap they are allowing our little basic trainees to do these days. I doubt there is much of the active-duty life I haven’t experienced, so to say I am somehow less then someone of my same rank and half my age is pure ignorance.
I agree the Guard needs more training in some areas and needs to be brought up to speed on navigating Army red tape channels, but to somehow say I am not equal to any soldier is a load for our lovely port-a-potties here in the sand. I had a 15-month tour in Iraq under my belt when I deployed this time, and I can tell you from our trip to the National Training Center that training was a waste of money and time.
I guess I am just sick of this constant bashing of the Guard. I can’t name every article written about them because I go out doing route clearing every day, but I could go next door to the active-duty unit and ask them. That is, if they can take a break from volleyball to answer. Is this one team one fight or is it play one team against the other so neither catches on that we could have a lot of things better for us here?
Sgt. Charles BidwellMissouri National GuardBalad, Iraq
Shame on ‘religious’ protestsI am the widow of a veteran of the Navy, and both of our sons have been military, one 11 years in the Air Force, the other 20 years in Coast Guard and now a civilian employee of the Coast Guard in Sitka, Alaska.
I am so proud that the oldest son has joined the Patriot Guard in Sacramento, Calif. He was outraged at these so-called “religious” protests. I have viewed their [Westboro Baptist Church ]Web site, filled with Bible verses, even charts listing all the people killed by God for their wickedness. In all their quotations, I found none that give them, or anyone else, the right to act as judges of others, or to assume that God had appointed them to be his instrument of vengeance against “sinful” America in this shameful way.
While I am not in favor of the gay lifestyle in any way, or of weakening the Constitution where anyone’s freedoms are concerned, I am proud of the Congress for their action, and also of the Patriot Guard.
It is such a tragedy that the WBC folks fail to see that these men died so they can have the freedoms that they enjoy. I have an opinion of what God must think as he observes their actions. Thanks be to God for all our military.
Carolyn McElrathNocona, Texas
Pacific editionThere were no letters in today’s Pacific edition.
