By STARS STRIPES 
STARS AND STRIPES

European and Mideast editions(EDITOR’S NOTE: These are the letters that appeared in each edition of Stripes on this publication date. Click here to jump ahead to the Pacific edition letters)

An unconvincing victoryThe writer of “Post-WWII vs. post-Iraq war” (letter, Dec. 16) is correct: Upon surrender, the war with Japan was over. After being at war for over eight years, to include having two atomic bombs dropped on their cities, the Japanese wanted no more war. Estimated 3.2 million war dead.

On May 4, the German surrender was negotiated, and the German people were not interested in any more of the same they’d had for the last six years. Estimated between 6 million and 8 million war dead. Both countries had been beaten into submission to the point that any response they had to American aspirations for their countries was the 1945 equivalent of “Whatever …”

You may be correct in thinking that our leaders expected the Iraqis to act like defeated Germans and Japanese. We expected a long, difficult war. What we received has been referred to as a “catastrophic victory.” It’s not nearly as convincing as the defeat of those great powers. Surely not convincing to the many people who are certain that Islam is destined to rule the world and there is honor in murdering yourself and whoever is standing too close, to include military personnel, civilians, women, children.

There are three ways this can end:

1. One day they’ll do the “whatever” thing and make an effort to live in the same world the rest of us reside.

2. Eventually, the last martyr will splatter themselves to glory and the rest of the world will walk away quietly and not look back.

3. We could give up now, run home to family and friends, and start walking post around our own houses ’cause the same people busy in Iraq now will be in Duluth, or Cleveland or Seattle. Is probably further in the future than I’ll likely experience. Just isn’t an option.

Jeff VandervortCamp Phoenix, Afghanistan

Post-WWII terrorismWith all due respect for what you lived through, your statements that once the Japanese and the Germans had done a terminal hands-up, then not one GI was IED’d or shot in the back, and “there simply were no ‘terrorists’ once Berlin and Tokyo had fallen,” are simply wrong (“Post- WWII vs. post-Iraq war”).

I can only assume that as “a houseboy for GIs in occupied Germany,” you had a limited picture of what actually occurred during the postwar reconciliation and reconstruction. Japan was easier than Germany (or Iraq), because the emperor who was worshipped as a god by his society told everyone to stop fighting. But in immediate postwar Germany, occupation was not a snap, as you said, nor “was [it just] a fun time for GIs with beer and jazz-frenzy Frauleins.” There were many Germans forced to live below subsistent levels and cultural tensions existed for many years.

It is not a direct comparison between occupied Iraq and Germany, but there are many parallels worthy of note. Indeed, some remnants of Hitler Youth, often financed and organized by ex-Nazi officers, carried out post-surrender attacks (sound familiar?) and GIs were killed. One of the reasons they were not as prevalent or successful as the current terrorists in Iraq was because there was better accounting of arms and ammunition after the surrender — instead of IEDs, a favorite tactic was wire strung across roads to decapitate Jeep drivers.

But the primary thing to remember (and what most people have forgotten) is that it took a long time, monumental effort and incredible (mostly American) resources to build a free, thriving democracy that is now a pillar of world society.

Please read “Endkampf: Soldiers, Civilians, and the Death of the Third Reich” by Stephen G. Fritz, a well-researched and documented account of the end of World War II and the beginning of peace.

Air Force Maj. Andy RhudeEinsiedlerhof Air Station, Germany

An apology and a cowbellI was one of those “young officers” who rushed blindly to support the president (“Justified on a technicality,” letter, Dec. 11).

The letter writer is right. I am wrong. I apologize for blindly supporting “Chimpy McHalliburton” and his “Axis of Destruction.” I apologize for thinking the follow-up to Resolution 1441 (which promised “serious consequences”) was political cover for Tony Blair to push the war against Saddam Hussein past his back benchers and triangulate the Lib Dems. I apologize for recalling that then French Foreign Minister Dominique de Villepin sandbagged Secretary of State Colin Powell in January 2003 at the U.N. anti-terrorism conference, implying that France would veto the second resolution.

I apologize for reading subsequent Volcker Commission reports credibly implicating sundry French politicians, members of the Russian Office of the President, George Galloway, Father Benjamin, and others, in accepting oil vouchers (to say bribes would be gauche) from Saddam.

I apologize for believing in cause and effect. I apologize for not believing that the democratic, free United States should submit to that great and good deliberative body that is the United Nations, where Cuba, Sudan, North Korea, Saudi Arabia and Liechtenstein are in good standing. I apologize for thinking that the United Nations is hamstrung by national, corrupting influences.

I apologize for thinking China’s security relationship with, and investments in the oil sector of, Sudan essentially block any action against the Janjaweed (Sudan militia). Anyway, they’re not my people. While I’m at it, I apologize for the Kyoto Treaty being unsigned by the “Toxic Texan.” I apologize for our emissions going down, while Canada’s go up, and the European Union does nothing. It’s better to feel good than do good.

Most of all, I apologize for not believing that this world is governed by an enlightened, humanitarian impulse, with only the actions of that rogue Great Satan, marring global harmony, peace and social justice.

Can I have a cowbell, now?

My apology and $2.50 ought to get you a cup of coffee.

Capt. F. Cameron JacksonBagram Air Base, Afghanistan

What ‘recalling’ meansThe premise on which the writer of “Justified on a technicality” based his argument is extremely flawed.

The only false technicality was the writer’s interpretation of U.N. Resolution 1441. He writes “with [U.N.] Resolution 1441, all previous resolutions were recalled.” This statement is simply and utterly wrong. U.N. Resolution 1441 did not recall any of the previous U.N. resolutions directed toward Iraq. In fact, nowhere in U.N. Resolution 1441 was the word “recalled” used. Resolution 1441 started off by “Recalling all its previous relevant resolutions. …” The word “recalling” in addition to “further recalling,” “deploring” and “affirming” is part of the complex lexicon of U.N. resolution writing and speech. In the context of U.N. Resolution 1441 the term “recalling” is used as a synonym for “referencing” or “referring to,” not “null and void.”

I am not a jingoist and only in rare cases do I support unilateralism in foreign affairs. Regardless of what the letter writer’s quixotic beliefs may be, the war in Iraq was not unilateral. You may mock President Bush’s coalition of the willing, but the fact remains that there currently is a coalition of sovereign, independent nation-states that decided to do the hard right besides the easy wrong; daily fighting, dying and sacrificing thousands of miles away from home to help make Iraq a better place.

For 12 years Saddam Hussein made a joke of the United Nations that resulted into its current illegitimacy. For your sake, it is unfortunate this war could not be validated through the United Nations; however, the job had to be done and Saddam had to go.

Capt. Luke D. CoffeyBagram Air Base, Afghanistan

Pacific editionReal reason for the seasonThe news lately is full of rants about store workers greeting customers with “Happy Holidays.” It is time to set the winter celebration record straight.

There is no religious basis for a winter Christmas. The winter dates were selected as an effort on the part of the church to absorb pagans who celebrated the Saturnalia festival or winter solstice. Much of Europe had celebrated for centuries the peak winter days with feasting and drinking.

Christmas was taboo in Boston from 1659 to 1681 to prevent anyone from enjoying themselves. After the American Revolution, things English fell out of fashion and the Christmas holiday crept back into use, becoming a U.S. holiday on June 26, 1870. Flying reindeer, a fat man coming down the chimney, chopping down trees and putting them up in the living room, sending cards to people we make an effort not to see all year, office parties with people we don’t especially like and terrible television programs have all become part of the tradition.

The fact is that today Christmas is a secular holiday. Christian churches continue to insist that the holiday belongs to them. Their constant nagging about the “reason for the season” reminds me of advertisements placed in writers’ magazines reminding us that a trademark is a noun and not a verb. Companies continually take steps to prevent the use of their names in a generic manner, i.e., “I’ll just go and acme this letter.” Acme wants us to photocopy the letter on an Acmephotocopy machine. Otherwise, the name slips into the public domain.

And so it is with Christmas. If the churches don’t nag us continually to remember the “reason for the season,” Christmas may slip into the public domain and they would lose all proprietary rights to make money from it.

So, you holiday merrymakers, I wish you and yours a very happy winter solstice, the real reason for the season.

Maj. Peter W. Barber (retired)Würzburg, Germany

Chaplains will work with youTo the writer of the Dec. 15 letter “Chaplains don’t serve everyone”: I can’t believe that you would actually say that chaplains don’t serve a purpose [for all servicemembers]! I fumed when I read that letter.

I don’t go to church, but it doesn’t bother me when people practice whatever religion they are associated with. Have you ever heard the term “sacrifice the few, for the many”? I can guarantee that probably 90 percent of the military (all services) has heard or used this phrase. I like chaplains; in my case, they bring humor when it’s needed.

Across the board, the majority of people practice some form of Christianity, Islam or Judaism. OK, say those three “traditional” religions share an equal amount of followers (say 90 percent, total). Now look at the more “nontraditional” religions: Wiccan, Satanism or Jainism (say the last 10 percent, total). Now imagine you must spend money (a budget) on religion. Where would your money go?

So don’t be upset when your chaplain or local military church doesn’t know your religion; you may actually have to tell them about it so they can better serve you. They are there for you and everyone else. Chaplains must be the busiest people in the military. Not only do they listen, preach and comfort, they have to listen to that last 10 percent who don’t make an effort to inform their chaplains of their religions.

Staff Sgt. Christopher HamiltonKadena Air Base, Okinawa