European and Mideast editions(EDITOR’S NOTE: These are the letters that appeared in each edition of Stripes on this publication date. Click here to jump ahead to the Pacific edition letters)
Reserve, Guard mistreatedI am writing in response to the “Officer discredited Army” (letter, Dec. 2).
I wholeheartedly agree with the lieutenant’s assertion that Army officers should voice their political opinions behind closed doors and not in front of their soldiers. But, by pointing out that the captain he was chastising was a reservist, the lieutenant simply provided more ammunition to those who routinely criticize the reserves and National Guard.
As a member of the Missouri Army National Guard and garrison command at Logistics Support Area Anaconda, I have no delusions of grandeur about my role in support of Operation Iraqi Freedom, but this does not mean I will silently acquiesce to the criticisms continually leveled at the reserves and National Guard. Throughout the six months my unit has been mobilized, including the last three months spent on LSA Anaconda, I have had to watch as our soldiers have been unjustly besmirched and belittled, as well as denied awards and command positions, simply because of their status as National Guard soldiers. Even as some of our soldiers learn firsthand that bullets and mortars don’t discriminate, they also continue to learn that the active Army often does the convenient thing and not the right thing by the reserves and National Guard.
I put the blame for the continued mistreatment of the reserves and National Guard squarely on the officers and noncommissioned officers of the active Army who allow it to happen. My message to these officers and NCOs is either live the Army values and treat all soldiers with respect (i.e. One Army) or do the so-called second-class (reserve) and third-class (Guard) citizen-soldiers in Iraq a much-needed favor and shut up, because our soldiers deserve better.
Capt. Keith EssmyerLogistics Support Area Anaconda, Iraq
‘Justified on a technicality’In the defense of the captain who so boldly stated the obvious in “War based on a lie” (letter, Nov. 28): I completely agree that since the writer was an officer, he should have used more restraint and maybe not included his rank. It is not good for the morale of his men to read a letter like this. However, it is good to see there are some individual thinkers left out there.
The war in Iraq was a boldface lie told when Sept. 11 was fresh in our minds. One of the main causes of both the war, and the confusion that came with it, is U.N. Resolution 1441, adopted by the U.N. Security Council in 2002.
In this resolution, the council recalled its previous resolutions on Iraq, primarily Resolution 678 of 1990 and Resolution 687 of 1991. Resolution 678 came about when the council authorized the use of force “by any means necessary” against Iraq to remove them from Kuwait. Resolution 687 asked that Iraq eliminate its weapons of mass destruction. Resolution 1441 was passed because Iraq had not acted according to the previous resolutions. With Resolution 1441, all previous resolutions were “recalled.” Resolution 1441 did not include the option of “any means necessary.” Our “coalition of the willing” attacked before a vote against action could be made by the council. Resolution 1441 did not say we couldn’t “use any means necessary,” however, it did not say that we could, either.
Traditionally, when the option of war is on the table, the “any means necessary” clause is included. The war was justified on a technicality, and then discredited when these WMDs never turned up.
While I appreciate the enthusiasm of the young officers who responded in blind support of the president, I would offer a little advice: Sometimes it is better to say nothing than to ruin your credibility.
Daniel MedinaMannheim, Germany
Negativity serves no good endThis is in response to the writer of the Nov. 28 letter “War based on a lie”: Regardless of one’s stand on the war on terrorism, the battlefront in Iraq, weapons of mass destruction, etc., in identifying himself with his military rank as a military officer, rather than just using his given name and expressing his thoughts as a private citizen, the writer of “War based on a lie” should be made to face Uniform Code of Military Justice action for his reckless endangerment of other serving military members for that ridiculous diatribe of negativity he sent in.
You, sir, did nothing in that letter to offer a reasonable alternative solution or to suggest another course of action in any of the ridiculous, liberal-minded and opinionated assertions you’ve made. You have only served to stir the pot and add more fuel to the fire of negative assaults toward us from the left, the news media and uninformed, anti-war activists who continue their outcry to abandon the good cause that we have now committed ourselves to seeing through toward a better end in Iraq, and in the world at large. And that, sir, is, in a word, “pathetic” of you.
When you are speaking as a military servicemember, do us all a favor and be a team player. Keep your negativity between you and your military chaplain, or a qualified mental health professional. Because we don’t want to hear it! Enough said.
Chief Warrant Officer 3 Dean BaileyK-16 Air Base, South Korea
Pacific editionThere were no letters to the editor in today’s Pacific edition.
