By STARS STRIPES 
STARS AND STRIPES

European and Mideast editions(EDITOR’S NOTE: These are the letters that appeared in each edition of Stripes on this publication date. Click here to jump ahead to the Pacific edition letters)

Heroes, soldiers, chaplainsIn “U.S. shouldn’t fund chaplains” (letter, Nov. 14), the writer defaced the military importance of our chaplains by declaring them “biased faith-healers and spiritualists who offer the contradictory words of ancient soothsayers,” and saying, “Chaplains can’t understand what it’s like being a soldier.”

I’m not the type who attends religious services every week or prays at every meal; nor have I read the Bible. I do spend time with chaplains as a bugler for memorial services of fallen soldiers.

I arrived in Iraq as a truck driver and about a month later I performed taps at the service of a friend who was killed while escorting a supply convoy. The death was difficult to accept. Because of that and other direct-combat experiences, I have trouble sleeping, relaxing and performing taps. According to the letter writer, I should have been sent to mental health or continued suffering until I return home. Instead, I was referred to a chaplain. I didn’t go because I thought it wasn’t the soldierly thing to do and I wanted to prove I could handle it on my own.

Well, I couldn’t handle it on my own. I talked to a chaplain. He helped me without mention of religion. Because of that experience, I saw chaplains for what they really are — soldiers. Our noncombatant chaplains are just as much heroes as any of the best infantry combatants.

Many soldiers feel that praying before missions is extremely important and I’ve known it to be an honor that a chaplain took the time to pray with the unit. Whether the prayer is of protection, praise, or mission success, even I welcome prayer before missions. Perhaps servicemembers who find group prayers meaningless or unprofessional can find within themselves a tolerance through understanding that mission-oriented prayer is part of our military tradition.

God bless the United States, our military and our chaplains.

Sgt. Skip SpoerkeCamp Liberty, Iraq

Chaplains are neededI am the son of an Army chaplain and am now a chaplain assistant deployed to Iraq and have seen firsthand the need for chaplains (“U.S. shouldn’t fund chaplains”).

A majority of U.S. soldiers have a faith system of one type or another, and those are the soldiers we serve. It has never been, nor will it ever be, our place to push religion on anyone.

That does not mean that we sit in climate-controlled offices thinking about how great God is. A soldier’s faith and his well-being are the lane of the chaplain. Chaplains encourage that faith and help build upon its foundations, and very often you will see a chaplain moving among the troops to whom he is assigned, so that he can give an encouraging word to them.

It is evident the letter writer does not see a need in his life for the work of a chaplain, but that does not mean the soldiers around him share his view. Because I have never needed the services of a helicopter maintenance crewmember does not mean that it is not vital to another larger group of people beyond myself. And it does not mean that my life has not been made easier because they kept those birds flying.

There are secular alternatives to the counseling aspects of the chaplain. Mental health teams work with chaplains to keep soldiers mentally healthy. If the letter writer is displeased with his chaplain or the way the chaplain is being used in his unit, it is his duty to report to his chain of command how that chaplain has offended him.

Chaplains are soldiers. They train with us, they deploy with us. They share our joy and our pain and are sometimes the only people with strength left enough to encourage the people whose lives are affected by this war.

Spc. Damien MartsLogistics Support Area Anaconda, Iraq

The power to motivateRegardless of whether one is religious, the enormous power of religion to motivate servicemen and women to fight at the risk of life and limb for a cause endorsed by their “chaplaincy” can’t be ignored (“U.S. shouldn’t fund chaplains”). This power has undoubtedly existed since cavemen learned to talk and asked, “Why should I fight to defend my tribe?”

Yes, atheists may also be found in foxholes, but hardly in sufficient quantities to fight a war.

Armor we can do without, but chaplains, never! Have you met any suicide bombers lately?

Frank LeitnakerMiesau, Germany

Chaplains serve a purposeThe writer of “U.S. shouldn’t fund chaplains” must have had a very bad experience with a chaplain, because his letter, from beginning to end, is filled with anger and bitterness.

In his discussion, the writer forgot to mention the main reason there are chaplains in the U.S. military: Our government sends servicemembers to parts of the world where there are no “houses of worship.” Many would not remain in the military if there was no organized spiritual support available where they are being deployed.

Chaplains are forbidden to proselytize or use overbearing tactics to gain access to servicemembers. The vast majority of chaplains are aware of this policy and abide by it.

The writer’s statement, “Chaplains can’t understand what it’s like being a soldier, they are noncombatants” is erroneous. Many chaplains begin their career as enlisted men or officers in a wide range of military occupational specialties, and enter the ministry later.

Another error in the writer’s letter is his use of the words “biased” and “unbiased.” There is no such thing as absolute objectivity; no one is unbiased. All of us bring presuppositions (assumptions) to our discussion of any subject, such as what is right or wrong, or what is true and what is false. Another word for it is “perspective.” We cannot possibly escape our own perspective of our world, and of reality. Scientific “professionals” are just as biased as chaplains.

The real tragedy of this letter is the writer’s furious rejection of all that is faith-based. While that is his right as an American, fortunately he does not have the means to deny access to licensed, highly educated spiritual leaders by those who would defend our faith in God to the death.

Capt. Matt UlmenLogistics Support Area Anaconda, Iraq

Stripping GIs of a freedomThe writer of “U.S. shouldn’t fund chaplains” is right on for practicing his right to free speech. We should kick all religious aspects off of every military installation. If the soldiers want to practice their beliefs, have missionaries come and set up churches, but not on any forward operating base. They could set up the churches right outside the base and pay for their own security so as not to spend any taxpayer money. Then leave the choice in the commanders’ hands to either deny the soldier the right to practice their religion or send the soldier out the front gate under nongovernment-paid guards. They will be OK and, hey, if they are, God forbid, hurt by those who are looking to destroy any form of democratic stabilizing force, then that will just be one less religious crybaby that liberals will have voting against them come 2008.

Sarcasm aside, the writer may think his beliefs are nobler, but chaplains are here to most importantly assist commanders and ensure the soldiers who have religious beliefs are able to practice freedom of religion. Saying the “U.S. shouldn’t fund chaplains” is saying the U.S. should strip freedom of religion from every soldier forward deployed.

Free speech sounds better with a pinch of common sense. Soldiers coming up through the ranks always say: “The changes that guy wants to make don’t make any sense.” The letter writer just stepped over and became one of those guys.

Staff Sgt. Jason A. Krawietz Sr.Forward Operating Base Courage, Iraq

Pacific editionBetter yet: Use your own bagsI read your front-page headline on Nov. 14, “Every bag counts in checkout line,” and was disappointed to read the article because it made no mention of using your own grocery bags.

I understand that the Defense Commissary Agency is trying to keep its costs down by reducing the number of bags they use — and, by not automatically double-bagging groceries, they will save a lot of bags. If they encouraged customers to bring their own bags, they could reduce that even more.

In my hometown, grocery stores actually pay you to use your own bags, 10 cents off your grocery bill for each bag you brought that they didn’t have to supply you. Even if DECA didn’t want to pay their customers, they could at least make the canvas bags they do sell more visible and simply encourage people to use them.

If more people used canvas bags, backpacks or other reusable bags to carry their groceries, they would not only be keeping DECA’s costs down, but helping out the environment as well because then no bags — paper or plastic — are thrown away. Using your own bags can even make the trip home easier because they are stronger, especially on bases in the Pacific, where we often walk, ride a bike, take the bus or taxi home.

Nichole L. MonzonOsan Air Base, South Korea

First, ask the right questionsThis is in response to Sgt. Richard Himmel’s bashing of the Army and Air Force Exchange Service (“AAFES has wrong stock,” letter, Nov. 15). The problem here is Sgt. Himmel, not AAFES.

First, has he addressed the problem with AAFES managers and afforded them a chance to assist him? Better yet, has he been to his unit’s supply room to ask about these required items? Has he given them the opportunity to address his concerns? Has he spoken to his chain of command if the results of his inquiries were negative? What has he done for himself other than complain that no one is “supporting the troops”?

By the way, the reason the civilians can go to a Wal-Mart in the States, is because they can’t go to their company supply room for their individual needs. [Servicemembers should] use all the resources available to them before they begin bashing. AAFES cannot carry everything that everyone spread out in the, as Himmel put it, “vast battlefield of the war on terror.” I bet there are some soldiers, worse off than the letter writer, who wish their biggest worries were a lamp and all its accessories.

Bill HollenCamp Humphreys, South Korea

Don’t denigrate free speechIt’s interesting and disturbing to see so many letters, from people who supposedly are sworn to defend the Constitution of the United States, advocating the abridgement of free speech and freedom of the press, intolerance of opposing views, etc.

The term “liberal” has become a dirty word in the minds of some people; the term “moderate” doesn’t seem to be much better to them either. When did the ability to see and express an alternate point of view become an “un-American” activity?

American citizens have the right to express their opinions freely (with a few exceptions) and newspapers have the right to print the news, even news that some may find unpalatable. That’s the beauty of living in a free and democratic society — something that the writers of these letters seem to have lost sight of.

It disturbs me to see so many attempts to suppress opposing views and to discredit those who dare to express such views, seemingly more prevalent over the past five years. I’d expect that in a totalitarian state — like, say, North Korea — but not in the United States.

Supporting or not supporting whatever administration happens to be occupying the White House (or a war) doesn’t necessarily make one a good, or a bad, American citizen.

Some of the events occurring these days are reminiscent of the McCarthy era. Do these writers really want a return to those shameful days in America’s history? I certainly hope not.

David L. CarrollSeoul

Who oversees AAFES?Congress is looking into price gouging by major petroleum corporations because of billions of dollars in profits made during the last quarter.

What about Congress looking into the profits the Army and Air Force Exchange Service is making off military and Department of Defense civilian personnel in South Korea and Japan? Prices are going down in the United States, but AAFES keeps right on raising gas and diesel prices overseas. There is no valid reason AAFES should base gasoline pricing on the cost of gasoline in the U.S. AAFES’ pricing should be based on what AAFES pays for the gasoline.

AAFES should not be making a profit when it has a monopoly at all the bases. Does any government agency have oversight over AAFES? My next step is to write my North Carolina congressional delegation and asked them to look into AAFES business practices. I hope others do the same.

Darrell G. BrownSeoul

New comic strips welcomedI am completely in support of the recent changes to the comics pages of Stars and Stripes. I enjoy the new humor. “Get Fuzzy” is one of my favorite comic strips and it’s nice to have it in my daily paper instead of looking it up online.

For those who write in with complaints about the horrible new comics, claiming “Calvin and Hobbes” or “The Far Side” (both of which were retired 10 years ago) are the greatest thing ever and that you can’t get through your day without it, by all means, buy the anthology. They’ve been out of print for so long, you could probably find some books in the sale bin.

Out with the old, tired, continually repeated comics; in with the new. Give the new ones a try. It’s tough appealing to such a diverse audience, but I think most will find a few comics in the new mix that can bring a smile.

Elizabeth GenerasMisawa, Japan

Not content with ‘Lila’ contentThe sexual content of the comic strip “Meaning of Lila” is inappropriate. In the last few weeks the strip has featured a cross-dressing man, comments about tight-fitting sweaters and, with the Nov. 10 strip, it has started [discussing] straight, gay and bisexual men.

I let my son read the comics and I really do not want him learning about this stuff from a comic strip. Stars and Stripes is also used in the schools, elementary and above.

The other new strips may or may not be funny, but “Meaning of Lila” is in poor taste and inappropriate for some of your audience.

Keith DouglasYokosuka Naval Base, Japan

Let poll determine funniesStars and Stripes, if you really care what kind of comics your readers would like, why don’t you run a simple survey? There could be two formats: an online survey and a mail-in survey printed in the newspaper.

The survey could be something like this:

Are you in favor of continuing the new comics? Yes______No_____

Do you want the old comics back? Yes______No_____

You could run this or a similar survey and maybe determine what your readers really like.

Dennis SwainSchweinfurt, Germany