By STARS STRIPES 
STARS AND STRIPES

European and Mideast editions

(EDITOR’S NOTE: These are the letters that appeared in each edition of Stripes on this publication date. Click here to jump ahead to the Pacific edition letters)

Sending wrong message

I would like to comment on the article “Marine killed in Iraq hours after son’s birth” (Nov. 22).

If the Stars and Stripes were part of the mainstream media, going for ratings and money, I perhaps could see some reason (albiet not a decent one) for posting this tragic article.

But with the majority of the paper’s readers being deployed soldiers who get this newspaper for free, why would you post a story about an expecting father dying without knowing the joy of fatherhood?

I am currently serving in my third tour in Iraq, and my wife is expecting our first child while I am away. As I feel I am pushing the odds each time I go overseas, what kind of positive attitude am I to retain when hearing of such depressing news?

How does this help my wife (or the family of any soldier) maintain their morale and hopes of a safe return when stories of tragic irony are posted on the front page?

Yes, we are at war. Yes, people die. I’ve lost two friends since the beginning of operations. I feel that they should be honored and remembered as the heroes they were and not at all the tragic/irony that revolves around their death.

Your publication proclaims, (according to your Web site) to “enhance military readiness and better enables U.S. military personnel and their families stationed overseas to exercise their responsibilities of citizenship.” — Revised DOD Directive 5122.11.

I think the Stars and Stripes has failed miserably in this aspect as I can now imagine brave men and women on guard duty, too distracted by the constant bombardment of news stories like this (especially during the holidays) to maintain focus at a time where situational awareness is most needed.

You know in psychological operations, we are taught to never show friendly forces in a compromised position that can be used by the enemy for bragging/recruiting rights. Why doesn’t the American media try to follow suit?

Overall, I think you guys have a great publication, and I thought I was overreacting until my entire team starting expressing bitterness toward that article.

Sgt. Brett KarpowiczBaghdad

Giving back to docs

I would like to say thank you to Dr. J. Grow, of the Hanau Army Medical Center, and Dr. (Maj.) S.R. Hinds Jr., of the Landstuhl Regional Medical Center, and all the wonderful people in and around the Hanau military community for their friendly and spiritual inspiration given me throughout my difficult time.

They give me hope and their blessing and prayers.

In July 2002, I was diagnosed with lumbar spinal stenosis in my lower back. At times, I could hardly walk or sit without constant pain.

I was seen by several German doctors, but Grow was the driving force behind my physical outcome. He stuck with me and pushed to the every end.

In August 2003, I was sent to Walter Reed Army Medical Center hoping to be operated on, but my spine was not strong enough to withstand a major operation. Upon my return to Germany, I once again consulted with Grow.

Finally, I was put in contact with Professor Dr. Med. W. Dittmann at the Aschaffenburg clinic in Germany. I was operated on Nov. 12, 2003.

I’m presently at 97.5 percent, and still cannot lift more than 11 pounds.

I owe everything to Grow. If not for him, I would still be walking around bent over like a 90-year-old man. Thanks to Grow, Hinds, and all the wonderful people of the Hanau military community.

Roy A. SealeyHanau, Germany

Not fighting for NBA

This letter is in response to “pro athletes go too far” (Nov. 24).

I found it incredibly insulting that the writer would close his letter by saying, “is this what we are fighting for in Iraq?”

The writer was writing from England, therefore he is not fighting in Iraq. The fact that National Basketball Association, National Football League, National Hockey League or any other sports venue is associated with this fight is ignorant.

The writer, like a lot of other people, are using this forum to give their opinions validity. If the writer has served, or is being deployed down here to serve, then maybe he needs to rethink what it is he is going to be fighting for.

I and the other thousands of soldiers, airmen, sailors and Marines are fighting to keep terrorists out of America, not so a guy can make $5 million a year playing a game.

Sgt. Nick StansberryTikrit, Iraq

Pacific edition

Politics aside, respect ACLU

I must disagree with the Nov. 22 letter “ACLU has outlived usefulness.” First, the American Civil Liberties Union has not removed any liberties from the Boy Scouts of America. The court case was to remove federal funding from the Boy Scouts. Bases are no longer allowed to sponsor Boy Scout troops. That means that tax money and taxpayer resources will not be going to the Boy Scouts, requiring them to sink or swim on their own merits. The ACLU has not tried to get Boy Scout activities banned from military bases. Military members still may lead Scout troops and participate in them, and the Boy Scouts are still permitted to meet on military bases in areas used by other civilian organizations.

The simple fact is that Boy Scouts of America is not an arm of the government. It’s a civilian organization, a social group of sorts. The Officer’s Wives Sewing Circle isn’t going to get federal funding any time soon, the recreation and gaming social group that I’m a member of doesn’t get any special treatment, so why should the Scouts? Boy Scouts of America cannot have its cake and eat it too. BSA officials can decide who gets to join the group, they can require new members to take an oath that is religious in nature but, if they are to have those freedoms, they can’t receive federal funding to do so. The ACLU isn’t trying to make Scouting illegal; it is making the playing field equal for everyone.

I certainly do not think that the ACLU has outlived its usefulness in any way; on the contrary, it is required more these days then it ever has been. The ACLU defends all our rights, does it well, and is oftentimes the only group doing it. A lot of people object to the ACLU’s stance on making sure that church is separate from state. They feel that ours is a Christian nation, and that the Christian religion should be a part of our government. This is, however, directly contrary to the wishes of our Founding Fathers, particularly Thomas Jefferson and James Madison.

Jefferson in particular was strongly opposed to any union of religion and government, saying, “In every country and in every age, the priest has been hostile to liberty. He is always in alliance with the despot, abetting his abuses in return for protection to his own.” In light of that statement by the drafter of the Declaration of Independence, a man described by the White House Web site as a “powerful advocate of liberty.” it is easy to see why so many religious organizations, the Boy Scouts included, object to the ACLU.

Madison, for his part, said, “An alliance or coalition between Government and religion cannot be too carefully guarded against. … Every new and successful example therefore of a perfect separation between ecclesiastical and civil matters is of importance … religion and government will exist in greater purity, without rather than with the aid of government.”

I know a lot of people aren’t happy about it, but there is no legal justification for the military sponsoring the Boy Scouts, regardless of the benefits that the Boy Scouts may or may not provide. People may not like it, and people may wish the ACLU would just stop trying to defend freedom and liberty, but that’s the law of our land, love it or leave it. For my part, this court case certainly won’t make me stop my yearly donations to the ACLU.

Senior Airman John NixdorfKadena Air Base, Okinawa

Curfew getting old in S. Korea

U.S. Forces Korea leadership has now decided that the curfew previously imposed only on active-duty military members now must be extended to include all Department of Defense civilian contractors. It’s bad enough that 30- and 40-year-old noncommissioned officers and officers were being subjected to this, but now it includes DOD contractors, many who are retired military in our 50s and 60s. When is this nonsense going to stop?

It only serves to reinforce my belief that fundamentalist Christians should never be put in positions of authority. They simply cannot refrain from imposing their values on everybody under them.

How is it that only members stationed here in South Korea are cursed with this curfew? Let’s impose a curfew at every U.S. military base worldwide and spread the misery around a bit.

Charles LacySongtan, South Korea