European and Mideast editions
(EDITOR’S NOTE: These are the letters that appeared in each edition of Stripes on this publication date. Click here to jump ahead to the Pacific edition letters)
CIB not for him?
I have read Army Regulation 600-8-22 in regard to the Combat Infantryman Badge. Nowhere on my DD Form 214 does it say military occupational specialty 11B or any 11 series. I’m a combat engineer on paper.
I am attached to the 1/69th Infantry, not as a sapper, but as a 240B gunner in, you guessed it, an infantry squad.
So, am I good enough to fill this slot as an infantryman, to train with these guys for five months, and ride into combat with them, but not to wear a CIB? If you are going to tell me that the driver of my Humvee deserves it, but his gunner doesn’t, I’m not going to be happy.
Am I good enough to bleed with the infantry, to be called infantry during the fight and to fill the roster, but then tossed out once the dust settles and told I’m not infantry, that I can’t wear it? Three cheers for camaraderie.
I just think it’s a tad messed up that I will be the only one in our four-man stack that isn’t infantry enough to get the CIB. I guess the five months at Fort Hood, Texas, and National Training Center drilling over and over just don’t count. At least I’ll get a combat patch — all the distinction a mere engineer deserves.
Spc. Chris MorehouseIraq
Many perform infantry duties
I agree that the Combat Infantryman Badge should be awarded to infantrymen only. Just like the black beret, not all changes are for the better.
Infantry soldiers are not the only ones performing in a strictly infantry role. Let me tell you about the troopers from 4th Battalion, 5th Air Defense Artillery from the 2nd Brigade Combat Team, 1st Cavalry Division. They are on patrol for 12-hour shifts, 24 hours a day on what the State Department ranks as the second most dangerous route in Iraq and its surrounding neighborhoods. They do get to experience the joy of riding in a Bradley fighting vehicle in 120-degree heat.
They also conduct dismounted patrols. They man checkpoints, execute raids, cordons and searches, and escort convoys — all of the things one previous letter writer mentioned as his criteria for separating infantrymen from the rest of the Army (“Badge reserved for warriors,” Oct. 29).
My soldiers are engaged with rocket-propelled grenades and small-arms fire almost daily. The number of improvised explosive devices my battalion has encountered is well into the hundreds. To cap it all off, they have dealt firsthand with vehicle-based IEDs.
The results of these noninfantry soldiers’ work is three killed in action and 64 wounded in my battalion alone.
My noninfantry battalion isn’t unique. The 91st Engineer Battalion (Combat Support) is busy patrolling one of Baghdad’s worst neighborhoods and battalion members have also performed all of the above listed missions. Troops from the 2-12 Cav have been fighting almost nonstop for the past year. They are not eligible [for the CIB] because they are considered tankers. Bottom line is, all maneuver task forces, regardless of branch, are performing infantry missions.
I have not heard one of my soldiers complain about not being eligible for a CIB. They have something more important. The respect of their fellow troopers from the 2nd Brigade Combat Team “Blackjack.” Go ahead and proudly wear your CIB because you have earned it. Just don’t forget that you aren’t the only combat soldiers in Iraq.
Sgt. Maj. James N. RossCamp Blackjack, Iraq
Gouging on several fronts
I would like to start by echoing Benny Harper’s comments (“New AAFES gas policy unfair,” letter, Oct. 2); he hit the nail right on the head. Thanks, Benny, you are correct: The Army and Air Force Exchange Service has gouged a captive audience for years and in more ways then at the gas pumps.
I would like to know where the 67 percent of our money that AAFES officials claim they donate to Morale, Welfare and Recreation goes? Everyone, including myself, who uses any of the facilities offered by these two organizations is charged a fee of some kind.
The Sept. 19 Stripes article “AAFES to switch to monthly gas pricing” (Okinawa and Japan editions) paraphrased AAFES spokeswoman Sgt. 1st Class Amanda Glenn as saying: “In fiscal 2004 the price AAFES paid to the Defense Energy Supply Center for gas was $1.02 per gallon. The price projected for next fiscal year is $1.06.”
The Oct. 3 Stripes article “AAFES says price it pays for gas for Japan soon to rise 36 cents per gallon” (Okinawa and Japan editions) stated that AAFES will have to pay $1.38 per gallon from the same vendor. I see AAFES learned a lot from the Kerry flip-flop. Who are we to believe?
Based on AAFES’s average figure of 743,000 gallons per month pumped from Okinawa pumps alone — and at the inflated rate of $1.38 per gallon AAFES officials claim they will have to pay — they will still make a cool $265,155 profit from the price adjustment in October. And better yet, $334,485 will be realized from November’s price adjustment of 10 cents per gallon. That’s a cool half-million-plus in just two months. Where will it end?
After AAFES’s share (67 percent), of our money is donated to MWR, AAFES still will make a smooth $220,000 for the two months, just from the pumps alone — not bad for someone who doesn’t even have to pump it (self service).
What does it take to wake folks up to the reality that we are not required to pay state and federal taxes on our gas purchases? I’ve taken Benny Harper’s advice and wrote this letter to show we are being ripped off. No new taxes!
Robert CoreyYomitan, Okinawa
Drive on? No, thanks
So far, I have seen only one intelligent letter on the 343rd Quartermaster Company.
There have been too many letters with phrases such as, “Suck it up and drive on” or “We saluted the flag and executed our mission” or “Now it’s time to earn your college money and serve.”
It’s just pathetic. This isn’t a game. Catch phrases don’t save lives.
Going on and on and on about duty and country doesn’t save lives, either.
What about the duty the military leaders have to those under them? What about the duty the country has to provide the very best for the men and women who serve?
If we are going to wear the uniform, then we deserve the very best because we may be asked to give up our very life. Those 19 soldiers are heroes for what they did, because they took a stand for what was right and weren’t bullied or intimidated by those above them.
Leadership is about taking care of those under you, and not about being the one in charge.
Stop all this nonsense about following orders like some moron without a brain and start holding leaders (both political and military) accountable when they make decisions that needlessly endanger lives.
And to those 19 soldiers in the 343rd Quartermaster company: There are troops who support you and believe you did the right thing. You took a stand, not just for yourselves, but for every member of the military.
And for that you have our gratitude.
Spc. Russell SteadeleCamp Victory, Kuwait
Badge issue hits home
The Combat Infantryman Badge issue hit home in my unit, 69th Infantry out of New York, because we have a number of soldiers in my battalion who were pulled out of other military occupational specialty slots to round out the battalion for deployment to Iraq.
These guys are not infantry-MOS-qualified even though this is an infantry unit and they are not promotable or eligible for the badge.
When Gen. George C. Marshall created the award in 1943, he wanted to recognize the soldiers who perform the infantry mission as their primary assignment. Many soldiers of all fields participated in ground combat during World War II; however, Marshall felt that only soldiers who performed the infantry mission full time should get the special recognition of the badge.
During current operations, again soldiers of all branches get caught up in ground combat from time to time, yet afterward they go back to their regular assignments, possibly out of harm’s way during much of their time in theater. I don’t think granting these soldiers the CIB would be in keeping with Marshall’s intent for the award.
However, the non-MOS-qualified soldiers serving with us are a different story. They have been assigned to an infantry unit and been given the infantry mission full time. They should be MOS-qualified by on-the-job training and made eligible for promotions within the unit and the CIB.
The Army might look at all who have been retrained and given the infantry assignment as their full-time job in the same light, reclassifying their MOS for the duration of their deployment.
Spc. Patrick O’DriscollCamp Buehring, Kuwait
No bell-bottom blues
Regarding the proposed new Navy uniforms (“Navy to test out cammie ‘working uniforms,’” article, Japan edition, Oct. 23): This idea [stinks]. Sailors have always rejected a change in their uniform because they felt they were unique. This change is just another way to further homogenize individuals, so that servicemen are interchangeable as indistinguishable numbers.
I suspect this idea came from a clerical or accountant-type mind, perhaps with the idea of keeping up with fashion, rather than honored tradition. No more bell-bottom trousers? Give us a break!
Bill ShannonLos Angeles
Consider benefits of adopting
November is National Adoption Awareness Month, established in 1990. It is a time to inform society about adopting, particularly for those children in foster care. The month also serves as a time to commemorate all the lives that have been touched through adoption.
Every year, Americans adopt thousands of children, either domestically or internationally. Unfortunately, there are even more children left in foster homes waiting to be placed. Most of these children are minorities, older children, have special needs, or all of the above.
Adoption is a unique way to build a family. I have experienced this personally. Three years ago, my husband and I adopted our son. We had a wonderful experience, and our son is the joy of our lives. We are thankful for him, and for his birth mother, who made a very loving sacrifice to find him a stable, two-parent home.
Please take a moment this month to celebrate the joys of adoption, or find the opportunity to learn about the process.
LaShea UdoakaRamstein, Germany
