3M continues to deal with lawsuits regarding defective earplugs, PFAS chemicals
By DEE DEPASS | (Minneapolis) Star Tribune | Published: January 21, 2020
MINNEAPOLIS (Tribune News Service) — Another 300 lawsuits against 3M flooded federal courts this month as more military veterans accuse the behemoth manufacturer of knowingly making defective earplugs that permitted them to lose hearing during combat in Iraq or Afghanistan or while training on U.S. military bases.
On another front, 3M also is fighting lawsuits related to a class of chemicals known as Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances, or PFAS, with the state of Michigan filing a lawsuit last week against the Maplewood-based company.
To date, nearly 2,000 U.S. veterans from Minnesota to California and Texas have filed more than 1,000 lawsuits.
New earplug lawsuits against the Maplewood-based 3M have been landing almost daily. Army, National Guard and Navy veterans from Minnesota to California and Texas are demanding jury trials and compensation.
3M denied the allegations and said it will defend itself in court. It said in court documents that 3M and the Aearo Technologies entity it acquired in 2008 designed its “dual-ended Combat Arms earplugs” with the help of the U.S. military and according to its specifications. Therefore, 3M cannot be liable, the company said.
“3M has great respect for the brave men and women who protect us around the world, and their safety is our priority,” 3M said in a statement Friday.
The company reiterated that it worked with the U.S. military to develop the “Dual Ended Combat Arms Earplugs Version 2” product, and its design reflected the direction and feedback of individuals acting on the military’s behalf.
“We deny this product was defectively designed and caused injuries, and we will vigorously defend ourselves against such allegations,” the 3M statement said.
However, many of the lawsuits point to internal Aearo documents, alleging the company knew the earplugs could slip and might not have been long enough to fully protect military members’ ears from loud noises.
The earplugs were designed to give soldiers options, depending on whether they inserted the green end of the earplug or yellow end. One option was supposed to block out all noises. Inserting the other end, however, was supposed to let soldiers hear critical voice commands while still blocking damaging noises such as explosions. Veterans say that didn’t happen.
The initial lawsuit against 3M came six months after the company agreed in December 2018 to pay military branches $9.1 million to settle government allegations that it supplied defective earplugs. The company did not admit guilt in the settlement.
In the past year, more than 150 lawsuits were filed in U.S. District Court in Minneapolis. Many of the cases, including those from Minneapolis, are being consolidated in the Northern District Court of Florida as a “multidistrict litigation,” or MDL. Under the MDL process, the judge will hear one “bellwether” case that then could determine how most others would proceed.
As of Jan. 21, more than 1,000 cases transferred to the MDL court in Florida, according to federal court records filed Tuesday.
The earplug lawsuits represent just one of two major court battles 3M is waging.
Hundreds of cities, states and individuals are suing 3M for allegedly contaminating rivers, drinking water, groundwater and soil with a class of chemicals known as PFAS. 3M is embroiled in more than 187 PFAS lawsuits.
PFAS chemicals, certain types of which 3M has made since the 1950s, recently have been found in 1,361 sites and rivers nationwide, according to the advocacy group The Environmental Working Group.
Insurance firms, Wall Street analysts and environmental risk analysts estimate that the long-lasting PFAS chemicals could end up costing 3M between $7 billion and $32 billion in product liability, litigation and pollution cleaning expenses. Fresh lawsuits and regulatory proposals keep mounting.
The state of Michigan sued 3M last week, following 2019 lawsuits filed by the states of Minnesota, New York, New Hampshire, Vermont and New Jersey and by a two water authority in Alabama. Earlier this month, The U.S. House of Representatives proposed new PFAS regulations.
3M settled with the state of Minnesota almost two years ago, agreeing to pay a historic $850 million to help with water filtration and pollution cleanup. In April, 3M agreed to pay $35 million to settle a PFAS contamination lawsuit by Alabama water authorities.
3M said it will defend itself against the new flood of PFAS lawsuits but added that it has continued to work with municipalities near its factories and dumpsites that were affected by PFAS leaks.
3M ceased producing two key types of PFAS chemicals — perfluorooctanoic acid and perfluorooctanesulfonic acid — in 2002 but continues to make “shorter-chain” versions of the compounds.