Naples, Milan rank last on European eco-friendly list
July 8, 2006
NAPLES, Italy — Sometimes, Mount Vesuvius disappears.
It simply vanishes, hiding behind a thick layer of smog that settles on this seaside southern Italian city.
That stifling air pollution, in part, lent to the classifying of Naples as the least eco-friendly city in Europe, according to a story published Thursday by the Italian wire news service ANSA, citing a study by Italy’s Environmental Research Institute in collaboration with environmental lobby firm Legambiente.
To reach its findings, the institute studied 26 cities in Europe, using 20 “eco-indicators” to measure how eco-friendly each is in areas such as the number of parks, pedestrian and cyclist zones, the level of pollution, and the efficiency of trash collection and sewage systems.
Naples ranked dead last, followed by the northern Italian city of Milan, Italy’s fashion and financial capital. Rome was third from the last. Helsinki, Finland, topped the study as the best eco-friendly city, ANSA reported.
Naples is home to more than 6,000 Americans, here as military members, dependents, contractors or civilians. The news wasn’t surprising to those breathing the polluted air and driving past the mounds of uncollected garbage that spill out of trash receptacles and litter roadways.
“You can tell when you go to another city outside the area,” said Petty Officer 2nd Class Zachery Metcalf, who has been stationed in Naples for two years. “After the work days, there’s always smog covering Vesuvio (Mount Vesuvius). Then, after a good rain, on Sunday, you can finally see the thing.”
“I can sort of believe it, yeah,” Petty Officer 2nd Class Derrick Thomas, of Naval Computer and Telecommunications Station, said about the environmental institute’s finding. “I figured it’d be on that list somewhere.
“There’s more trash here than in the States,” said Thomas, who has lived in Naples since October. “In the States we don’t have mounds of trash on the street.”
The Navy does what it can to make life better for sailors and their families, said Navy spokesman Chief Petty Officer John Musser.
“While the environmental study was not conducted by or for the Navy, our personnel and their families stationed in the Naples area have a wide variety of recreational facilities available both at the Gricignano support site and Carney Park,” Musser said.
Carney Park is 5 miles from the Capodichino base in a 93-acre extinct volcanic crater, which boasts a nine-hole golf course, Olympic-size outdoor swimming pool, softball and baseball fields, tennis courts, two batting cages, a basketball court, sandlot volleyball courts, horseshoe pits, picnic sites, paintball fields, and camping facilities, base spokeswoman Chief Petty Officer Dawn Scott said.
This week’s findings mark the second time in two years that Naples has received low marks for its environment.
In 2004, the Sesto San Giovanni Hospital’s occupational health department in Milan released results of a pollution study that found Naples residents breathe in the equivalent of nine to 11 cigarettes’ worth of pollution per day. The local government has made efforts to improve the air quality, such as imposing “black out” days on driving.
For those in Italy, there’s always the bright side of travel, Musser said.
“Personnel stationed in Naples also have the opportunity to experience such beautiful places as Amalfi, islands such as Ponza, Capri or Ischia, or even other cities elsewhere in Europe.”