Trump and Erdogan ask the same question about the killing of Khashoggi: 'Where's the body?'
By CHICO HARLAN AND JOHN HUDSON | The Washington Post | Published: October 27, 2018
ISTANBUL — Twenty-four days after a team of Saudi agents killed journalist Jamal Khashoggi at the Saudi consulate in Istanbul, U.S. and Turkish officials are still asking the same question: Where's the body?
The remains of The Washington Post columnist are critical to vetting the shifting accounts of the Saudi government and determining a suitable punishment for the oil-rich monarchy, a key partner in the Trump administration's Middle East policy.
Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan intensified pressure on the Saudi government on Friday in a speech demanding Khashoggi's body.
"There has been a declaration that he has been killed, but where is the body?" Erdogan said. "You must show it."
For days, President Donald Trump has also been asking his aides about the body, but Washington remains in the dark about its whereabouts, according to U.S. officials and diplomats familiar with the situation.
Saudi officials said earlier this week that Khashoggi's body had been rolled into a carpet and given to a "local collaborator," but Turkish authorities say it was dismembered in a grisly operation involving a bone saw and large suitcases.
"Finding the body in whatever form it's in could give credence to Turkey's account," said Amanda Sloat, a Turkey scholar at the Brookings Institution. "If the body appears in the way the leaks suggest, it gives credence to the premeditated nature of this attack and reflects poorly on the Saudi regime."
On Thursday, CIA Director Gina Haspel briefed Trump about her recent trip to Turkey, where she listened to purported audio of Khashoggi's killing. But even after the meeting, U.S. officials made clear they needed additional information before taking further punitive action.
"We continue to seek all relevant facts in this case," said State Department spokesman Robert Palladino. "As we learn more we will take additional actions as the facts warrant."
A State Department official said Khashoggi's remains "should be located and returned to his family for a proper burial as soon as possible."
In his speech, Erdogan suggested that Turkey has additional "information and documents" about the killing that it would eventually reveal and repeated his call for Saudi Arabia to hand over the 18 people it has arrested in the case if the country's authorities could not "make them talk." Later in the day, the semiofficial Anadolu news agency reported that Turkish prosecutors were set to "demand" the extradition of those suspects.
"Hand them over to us," Erdogan said. "The event took place in Istanbul. We will judge them."
A senior Turkish official said Turkey was requesting the extradition because Khashoggi was murdered by Saudis who traveled to Turkey, and because it was "clear that the judicial system in Turkey is better equipped to genuinely serve the cause of justice in this case."
In their own ways, Turkey and the U.S. are pressing Saudi Arabia to provide a credible explanation for a crime that has drawn global condemnation and has prompted countries to reevaluate their ties with the Middle East power.
U.S. and foreign officials say such an operation - involving a team of Saudi agents - was unlikely to have taken place without the knowledge of the kingdom's leaders, including ambitious Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman.
In the aftermath of Khashoggi's killing inside the Saudi Consulate on Oct. 2, Saudi Arabia has offered shifting explanations for what happened, at one point saying Khashoggi had walked out of the rear of the building unharmed and later saying his death resulted from a fistfight. But Thursday, the country made its first apparent acknowledgment that the operation was "premeditated." Erdogan on Friday did not mention that development, but instead criticized earlier Saudi accounts as "comical."
"These childish statements do not coincide with the seriousness of the state," Erdogan said.
For Erdogan, who has ruled Turkey since 2003, the crime has provided grounds for pushing back against Saudi Arabia, one of its regional rivals, and weakening the credibility of the crown prince. Mohammed this week called the killing a "heinous crime." Both Mohammed and his father, King Salman, have told President Trump and Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, who traveled to Saudi Arabia last week, that they had no knowledge of a plot to kill Khashoggi.
Still, the Trump administration is facing pressure to take action against the kingdom, even though an alliance with the Saudis has been a pillar of its strategy in the Middle East to counter Iran. Trump has called Khashoggi's murder "one of the worst coverups in the history of coverups."
In its statement Thursday, Riyadh said it had learned from Turkish officials that the suspects in Khashoggi's killing had "committed their act with a premeditated intention." The Saudi news release, attributed to its public prosecutor, was significant because it relayed Turkey's conclusion, but it did not make clear whether Saudi investigators had reached that same conclusion on their own.
Pompeo, speaking during an interview Friday with conservative radio host Hugh Hewitt, said "Saudi prosecutors yesterday made clear that this was a premeditated murder that took place, and we're continuing to learn the facts."
"The president has made very clear we will hold those responsible accountable, but that America has important, long-term, strategic interest in our relationship with the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and that we are going to do both of those things at the same time - protect our interests and hold those responsible accountable," Pompeo said.
Khashoggi was visiting the Saudi Consulate in Istanbul to obtain documentation that would allow him to marry his Turkish fiancee, Hatice Cengiz. He was a royal court insider who had become critical of the Saudi government, and he was living in exile in Virginia, in part because of the nation's diminished speech freedoms and its crackdown on dissent.
Khashoggi and Cengiz had recently furnished an apartment for themselves in Istanbul. In an interview with Turkish broadcaster Haberturk that aired Friday, Cengiz said Khashoggi was treated well during an earlier trip to the consulate on Sept. 28.
He still had concerns, but "he thought Turkey is a safe country, and if he would be held or interrogated, this issue would be swiftly solved," Cengiz said, according to an account of the interview translated by Reuters.
Salah Khashoggi, the eldest son of Jamal Khashoggi, arrived in the U.S. Thursday after departing Saudi Arabia, one person close to the family said. Salah is a dual U.S.-Saudi citizen who had previously been restricted from leaving and who was photographed earlier this week meeting Salman and Mohammed and receiving their condolences. All four of Khashoggi's children are now in the U.S.
Hudson reported from Washington. The Washington Post's Josh Dawsey and Kareem Fahim contributed to this report.