Saudi Arabia makes friends with an old enemy - Iraq
By ABBAS AL LAWATI AND DONNA ABU-NASR | Bloomberg | Published: May 12, 2019
The border between Saudi Arabia and Iraq is a line in the sand that says much about the Middle East's instability over the past three decades.
It was shut in 1990 after Saddam Hussein's invasion of Kuwait triggered the Gulf War. The Saudis proposed building a $7 billion barrier to seal it in 2006 as sectarian violence escalated. Then the rise of Islamic State prompted the kingdom to strengthen the 560-mile frontier.
With the extremist militants driven out of Iraq, Saudi Arabia is preparing to reopen the land crossing to trade this year because of the latest conflict that's dominating the region: its proxy war with Iran. In a stark reversal of policy, the kingdom has identified Iraq as a timely ally in curbing the influence of its Shiite enemy, which on Wednesday threatened to abandon commitments made in its 2015 nuclear deal in response to American sanctions.
The Saudis have been flexing their diplomatic and financial muscle. A ministerial and business delegation visited Iraq last month and came away with a pledge to invest $1 billion in development projects and open a consulate in Baghdad. Saudi Arabia has also employed other soft power tactics such as offering to build a sports stadium and government-backed broadcaster MBC recently announced a dedicated channel for Iraq. Clerics in the kingdom have been toning down their anti-Shiite rhetoric.
Saudi Arabia's aim is to prop up a government in Baghdad whose authority has been challenged by Iran-sponsored militias and bring the nation back firmly into the Arab fold, according to Ibrahim al-Nahas, a member of the Saudi Shura Council's Foreign Affairs Committee.
"We want to help Iraq be a strong country" Al-Nahas said in an interview in Riyadh last week. A Saudi rapprochement with Iraq "will decrease the influence of Iran inside Iraq" and the whole region, he said.
Iraq has been dominated by non-Arab Iran after the majority Shiites took over power following the 2003 U.S.-led invasion. Saudi Arabia now considers Iraq as a potential bulwark against Iran rather than a puppet state controlled by Tehran. It wants to show the problem is not with Shiites, but with Iran, which the kingdom believes has been meddling in Arab affairs.
To the south, Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman has led a disastrous military campaign against Iranian-backed rebels in Yemen. It's drawn condemnation from western allies just as they distance themselves from Saudi Arabia over the murder of columnist Jamal Khashoggi.
On the western front across the Red Sea, the Saudis have been co-opting the Iran-allied regime in Sudan. The kingdom and the United Arab Emirates, its closest ally, pledged a $3 billion economic support package for the African country after longtime dictator Omar al-Bashir was toppled last month.
Iraq, the largest Shiite population in the predominantly Sunni Arab world, has been receptive to Saudi Arabia as the leadership in Baghdad seeks to benefit from both powers.
On a state visit to Riyadh last month, Iraqi Prime Minister Adel Abdul Mahdi oversaw the signing of 13 agreements whereby Saudi Arabia pledged to pump a billion dollars into its neighbor's economy. It was the culmination of diplomacy that started in October 2017 when the two countries set up a coordination council and declared their intention to reopen the border at the Arar crossing, which is scheduled for October this year.
"We are witnessing a major transformation in relations with the kingdom," Abdul Mahdi said before his visit. Saudi capital can be used to help rebuild the country after the defeat of Islamic State and its energy and agricultural expertise can help develop Iraq's own industries, said Mohammed Hanoon, the Iraqi trade ministry spokesman. "The door is wide open," he said.
Making a dent in Iran's presence will prove difficult, though the Saudis have the money. There's also support from the U.S., which still has personnel stationed in Iraq.
Secretary of State Mike Pompeo made an unannounced trip to Baghdad on Tuesday to urge Iraqi leaders to beware of Iranian forces and allies. Washington has increased sanctions on Iran after withdrawing from the agreement on developing its nuclear capabilities.
The government in Tehran said it would resume uranium enrichment beyond agreed limits in 60 days if Europe can't find a way to ensure it can sell oil and trade with the world.
The Saudis "have been relatively successful" in Iraq, said James M. Dorsey, senior fellow at Singapore's S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies and its Middle East Institute. "They need, however, to follow up on promises and capitalize on the fact that, unlike the Iranians, they have the cash to do so."
Indeed, Iraq is saturated with Iranian influence, from its economy to politics and the powerful Shiite militias.
The Islamic Republic exported more than $1.66 billion worth of tomatoes alone to Iraq in 2017 and is the country's top source of everything from pig lard to human hair. Iran jumped from the Arab nation's fifth biggest non-oil exporter in 2016 to its biggest in 2017, bypassing China. Iraqi supermarket shelves are often stocked with cheap Turkish and Iranian products.
Al-Nahas said the kingdom tried to make inroads with former Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki, who was in power between 2006 and 2014, but to no avail. "He was working for Iraq to be part of Iran," he said.
As the U.S. pushes Iraq to stop buying natural gas and electricity from Iran, President Hassan Rouhani wants it to purchase more to help mitigate American sanctions. "Being in Iraq feels like being in our own country," Rouhani said during a three-day state visit to Baghdad in March. "It's not a link that can be weakened and we are always keen to make it stronger."
The two countries signed transportation and trade agreements and announced an end to visa charges for each other's citizens. Rouhani said officials planned to boost bilateral trade to $20 billion from the current $12 billion.
"I don't think there's any illusion in Riyadh that Iraq will sever relations with Iran," said Mohammed Alyahya, editor-in-chief of Saudi-owned Al Arabiya English news site.
The key is energy. For the Saudis, Iraq's drive to rehabilitate its war-ravaged industry to become the third-largest producer of new crude by 2030 presents an untapped market for Saudi products and companies.
There's about $15 billion of investment in oil and gas exploration and production expected every year between 2018 and 2030, the International Energy Agency said.
After Iran cut off power to Iraq because of payment disputes last year, Saudi Arabia offered to sell it to Baghdad at a fraction of Iranian prices.
As part of its outreach to Iraq, Saudi Arabia has also softened its position on Shiite Islam, long seen as antithetical to the official Wahhabi creed of the kingdom. In a nod to its often restive Shiite minority mainly in the east, Riyadh plans to open a consulate in the Iraqi holy city of Najaf, to which many Saudi Shiites travel for pilgrimage.
Government-backed clerics and televangelists who would regularly dismiss Shiites as heretics have either fallen silent or publicly disavowed their former positions.
Still, Saudi Arabia continues to detain and even execute Shiites in large numbers on suspicion of spying for Iran, among other charges. But notably, Iraq has lately refrained from publicly criticizing Saudi Arabia's treatment of its Shiites.
"We have different views from before," said Al-Nahas. It follows the July 2017 visit of firebrand Shiite cleric Muqtada Al Sadr, who was invited to Jeddah by the crown prince, publicly embracing one of Iraq's most powerful political figures. "It was a sign toward Iraq in general," Al-Nahas said.
Bloomberg's Khalid Al Ansary, Glen Carey, Ladane Nasseri and Samuel Dodge contributed.
(c) 2019, Bloomberg.