Support our mission
"Prosecutor" Romonno Washington, a "lawyer" for the prosecution, cross-examines the defendant.

"Prosecutor" Romonno Washington, a "lawyer" for the prosecution, cross-examines the defendant. (Michael Abrams / S&S)

"Prosecutor" Romonno Washington, a "lawyer" for the prosecution, cross-examines the defendant.

"Prosecutor" Romonno Washington, a "lawyer" for the prosecution, cross-examines the defendant. (Michael Abrams / S&S)

"Defense lawyer" Ashley Spratley listens to testimony at a mock trial. At right in the foreground is Jerry Hatch, who teaches the class.

"Defense lawyer" Ashley Spratley listens to testimony at a mock trial. At right in the foreground is Jerry Hatch, who teaches the class. (Michael Abrams / S&S)

"Defense attorney" Randall Bryan, left, listens as "victim" Brittany Moultrie answers his questions during a mock trial held by Heidelberg High School's "Street Law" class Thursday on Patton Barracks.

"Defense attorney" Randall Bryan, left, listens as "victim" Brittany Moultrie answers his questions during a mock trial held by Heidelberg High School's "Street Law" class Thursday on Patton Barracks. (Michael Abrams / S&S)

"Prosecutor" Kendrick Ladd question's a witness at a mock trial held by Heidelberg High School's "Street Law" class.

"Prosecutor" Kendrick Ladd question's a witness at a mock trial held by Heidelberg High School's "Street Law" class. (Michael Abrams / S&S)

"Juror" Steven Dilfer, left, and judge Lt. Col. Brad Huestis listen as "defendant" Robert Washington testifies in his mock trial held by Heidelberg High School's "Street Law" class.

"Juror" Steven Dilfer, left, and judge Lt. Col. Brad Huestis listen as "defendant" Robert Washington testifies in his mock trial held by Heidelberg High School's "Street Law" class. (Michael Abrams / S&S)

HEIDELBERG, Germany — The victim in the rape case was a teenage girl, the defendant, a teenage boy.

But then, the prosecutors were teenagers, too. So were the defense lawyers, the witnesses, and all but one of the jurors in U.S. v. David Jones.

It was a mock trial, held Tuesday morning at the garrison’s courtroom on Patton Barracks as the culmination of a law class at Heidelberg High School.

According to prosecutors, the young woman had said no to her boyfriend’s request for sex and he’d forced her to anyway.

“We are here because of a cry for protection. Will you hear it?” Kendrick Ladd, one of several prosecutors asked the jurors in his opening statement.

But the defense told jurors that the young woman had lied — she had consensual sex with her boyfriend then brought rape accusations against him because she was, as attorney Daphne Vessiropoulos said in closing arguments, “a jealous woman scorned.”

Presiding in the courtroom was the judge, Lt. Col. Brad Huestis, a military judge and now chief of claims services for the garrison. Also present was Jerry Hatch, teacher of the “Street Law” class and a former military lawyer and judge.

The name “Street Law” is unfortunate, Hatch said, for a sober, straightforward class on criminal law and procedures. The name comes from the company that markets the class materials, programs and textbook.

Hatch has taught the class for several years and said it helps students learn not only about the law but also about problem-solving, strategy and their responsibilities as citizens.

“It’s an excellent class,” Ladd said, although not his favorite. His favorite class is U.S. government, also taught by Hatch.

Although the mock trial did not go into the detailed, anatomical specificity required in real rape trials, the lawyers did not shy away from the facts in a not atypical “date-rape” scenario as they built their case.

Why, a prosecutor asked the defendant, had he put a condom on in the bathroom on the night in question if he wasn’t set on having sex? And wasn’t it true, he asked, that in order to put on a condom, a man must have an erection?

“You’d reached arousal. Is that the point of no return?” prosecutor Romonno Washington asked in his fast-paced cross-examination of the defendant that turned out to be pivotal in the case.

In real life, date rape cases are difficult to prosecute because there are no witnesses other than the accuser and defendant, and often little evidence.

“We lose about half of them,” Huestis said.

So it was with the mock trial.

The prosecution had the accuser; her silk shirt, torn, prosecutors said, during the defendant’s attack; one faint bruise; and an expert witness who said, in her opinion, the accuser was indeed suffering from Rape Trauma Syndrome.

The defense had the accuser’s diary, which conflicted with her statement to police about how the shirt had been ripped; their own expert witness who said the defendant seemed like a great guy to him; a theory about the accuser’s jealousy; and the fact that the couple had had consensual sex before.

The defense also had a presumption of innocence and what appeared to be reasonable doubt.

After the jury returned from its 10 minutes of allotted deliberation time, Huestis asked, “Have you reached a verdict?”

“Guilty,” said the jury foreman, also known as Doris Brodie, high school assistant principal.

“We decided he was guilty because when he was on the witness stand he said he pulled her back [after she got out of bed],” Brodie said, as the applause from the courtroom subsided.

author picture
Nancy is an Italy-based reporter for Stars and Stripes who writes about military health, legal and social issues. An upstate New York native who served three years in the U.S. Army before graduating from the University of Arizona, she previously worked at The Anchorage Daily News and The Seattle Times. Over her nearly 40-year journalism career she’s won several regional and national awards for her stories and was part of a newsroom-wide team at the Anchorage Daily News that was awarded the 1989 Pulitzer Prize for Public Service.
twitter Email

Stripes in 7



around the web


Sign Up for Daily Headlines

Sign-up to receive a daily email of today’s top military news stories from Stars and Stripes and top news outlets from around the world.

Sign up