Alliance unity 'more important than ever,' NATO chief says as defense spending rises
By JOHN VANDIVER | STARS AND STRIPES Published: March 14, 2019
STUTTGART, Germany — NATO defense spending rose for the fourth year in a row in 2018, but Germany continues to lag behind and is on track to miss an alliance deadline that calls for significant increases by 2024, according to data released Thursday.
NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg touted gains by the alliance’s European members and Canada, saying 2018 saw a 4 percent overall increase and $41 billion in additional spending since 2016.
“And we expect that figure to rise to 100 billion by the end of next year,” Stoltenberg said during a news conference at his Brussels headquarters.
However, NATO’s 2018 annual report also showed that Germany — Europe’s largest economy — continues to make only small increases, even as the White House pressures its allies over their reliance on U.S. military might.
In 2018, German spending held steady as it spent 1.24 percent of GDP on defense, well short of the alliance 2 percent benchmark. All NATO members have pledged to reach that goal by 2024, but last year Germany said it expects to only spend 1.5 percent by the deadline. Even that lower number could be out of reach based on Berlin’s updated budgetary projections.
Now, Berlin plans to spend less on defense in 2019 than previously expected. Spending will drop from the anticipated 47.2 billion euro to 44.7 billion euro, German media reported Thursday.
The budget cutback comes at a time when Germany faces a military readiness crisis: none of the country’s submarines are currently operational, more than half its fighter planes are unavailable for missions and its tank inventory is low.
Stoltenberg said Berlin needs to do more when it comes to spending.
“Germany has, together with other allies, agreed to the defense investment pledge,” Stoltenberg said. “I expect all allies, including Germany, to make good on those promises.”
For NATO, the issue of defense spending has been all-consuming since the election of President Donald Trump, who views many alliance members as security free riders. And Trump has singled Germany out in particular for criticism.
While America’s GDP represents 50 percent of NATO’s total GDP, the U.S. accounts for 69 percent of defense spending among alliance members. Germany represents 10 percent of alliance GDP, but just 5 percent of defense spending, according to NATO data.
But European critics have pointed out that much of U.S. spending goes to parts of the world outside Europe — such as the Middle East, Asia and the Pacific — and does not directly benefit NATO. In contrast, almost all of the defense spending of European NATO members contributes directly to the alliance.
Trump’s frustration with the spending imbalance has resulted angry critiques of NATO overall. The president also has reportedly contemplated charging countries the full cost of hosting U.S. forces, plus a 50 percent premium.
When asked about Trump’s “Cost plus 50” idea, Stoltenberg said the concept had not been discussed inside NATO. He also said the presence of U.S. forces benefits both allies and the U.S., which is able to project its power beyond Europe form its bases there.
“It is part of our shared security, of our collective defense,” Stoltenberg said.
Still, Stoltenberg offered praise for Germany, which over the past four years has been boosting expenditures. In 2014, Berlin dedicated just 1.18 percent of GDP to defense.
Stoltenberg also highlighted the key role German troops play in Afghanistan and deterring Russian aggression in the Baltics.
But when allies meet next month in Washington, where NATO will mark its 70th anniversary, defense spending is likely to be high on the agenda.
While disputes over spending have raised concerns about alliance cohesion, Stoltenberg said allies remain united.
“At a time when some are questioning the strength of the transatlantic bond, we are actually doing more together — in more ways and in more places — than ever before,” Stoltenberg said. “Because we live in an unpredictable world, NATO’s unity is more important than ever.”