2nd ID lieutenant sentenced in Camp Casey sex assault
September 28, 2006
CAMP CASEY, South Korea — An Army second lieutenant was sentenced at a court-martial on Tuesday to one year in jail for sexually assaulting a private and making a false official statement afterward.
Second Lt. Phuong Quach of the 2nd Infantry Division’s 302nd Brigade Support Battalion also will forfeit his pay and be dismissed from the Army after serving his sentence, military judge Col. Gregory Gross said.
Quach was found not guilty of aiding and abetting two underage enlisted soldiers to violate a general order by serving them alcohol. In his decision, Gross cited the government’s failure to introduce documentation citing the general order’s date.
During the two-day trial, prosecutors Capt. Madeline Yanford and Capt. Marlin Paschal portrayed Quach as a sexual predator who used alcohol to entice enlisted soldiers.
Quach invited three junior enlisted soldiers to his quarters, then served them Jell-O shots made from soju liquor and topped them with high-proof rum, according to testimony. One of the privates said that he passed out, then awoke in the morning in Quach’s bed to find Quach clasping the private’s genitals.
On Tuesday, defense attorneys Capt. Karen Riddle and Capt. Lynn Williams offered a vision of Quach as a hard-working officer who cared about enlisted soldiers and was baited into a confession. The defense also emphasized that Quach did not force the soldiers to drink or to come to his barracks.
“This is not a case of preying and deliberate coercion of junior enlisted soldiers,” said defense counsel Riddle said. “This is a case of adults.”
Riddle said Army investigators coerced Quach into admitting guilt after, in a first interview, he initially denied touching a 19-year-old private’s genitals.
A criminal investigations agent testified he used multiple interview techniques in a second interview with Quach. The agent said Quach responded positively to a “mistaken identity theme,” during which the agent suggested that Quach thought the private was a female officer whom he knew.
Following that interview, Quach signed a new statement admitting to touching the private’s genitals.
The private said the assault has affected his formerly passive demeanor.
“It’s gotten to the point now where the smallest things get me … in a bad mood,” the private said. “It’s kind of disappointing. Maybe ‘depressing’ would be a better term.”
The private also said the incident has negatively affected his focus on work and his desire to remain in the Army. He continues to question whether he could have done anything differently.
“Why me?” he said to the court during the sentencing phase. “Was there something I did that made him think I’d appreciate or want that?”
Following the private’s testimony, multiple soldiers came forth as defense witnesses to show support for Quach, whom they said was an excellent officer who cared deeply for his family and friends.
Quach declined to speak on his own behalf but offered the court an unsworn written statement saying that he would never make the same mistake.
“I realize what I did was wrong and for that I apologize to everyone,” Quach wrote, according to counsel. “I strongly believe that I can overcome this misconduct and I can soldier on.”
During sentencing, Gross added the federal conviction would also mean that Quach would have to register as a sex offender upon return to the United States.