Though controversial, distance learning has benefited many students
By ANDREW J. CAMPA | Los Angeles Times | Published: August 7, 2020
Those annoying puffy spots under the eyes of eighth-grader Natalie Alvarez began to disappear, followed by the 10 a.m. hunger bouts and the midafternoon yawns — much to the Carson, Calif., girl’s delight and surprise.
At first, Natalie had resisted the distance learning thrust upon her when schools closed amid the coronavirus emergency.
“I was worried about the distractions of being home with my mom and my sister and doing extra chores,” Natalie said. “But then things changed.”
Things changed, too, for Marcos Adame, whose grades improved because he could spend more time on problematic subjects. They also changed for Sebastian Hernandez, who has more energy.
At a time when many of their peers struggle with isolation, uneven online teaching or lack of access to computers, a fraction of students have discovered that distance learning can offer a unique kind of relief — and they have thrived.
Educators and school psychologists stress that campus closures and the suspension of in-class learning have exacted harm on children, especially those who are not fortunate enough to have a quiet, comfortable study space or whose families are coping with deep hardships and illness brought on by the pandemic.
Natalie, Marcos and others have adapted well in part because their schools were experienced with online learning, and they had home support to help them.
Josephine Kim, a Harvard University lecturer and licensed mental health counselor, said children can be surprisingly adaptable and hardy.
“There are intrinsic characteristics that may allow a child to thrive more under the current circumstances,” she said. Children who are introverted or those “who process information internally and gain energy from time and space for introspection” would likely fare well.
Los Angeles Unified School District Superintendent Austin Beutner agreed that some students, especially adolescents navigating middle school, have excelled at home, away from the pressures of school and a strict routine. He praised Natalie’s school, the Harry Bridges Span School in the Wilmington area of Los Angeles, as an example of one doing “extraordinary work” with online learning.
Steve Skrumbis, principal at Harry Bridges, said his school had an online component to its instruction before the spread of COVID-19, giving his staff and students a head start when schools closed in mid-March.
Before then, Natalie’s mornings consisted of 6:30 a.m. wake-up calls, half-consumed breakfast shakes, rushing out of the house at 7:55 and a tense ride to school, worried that she’d be late for first period at 8:15.
With online learning, Natalie could roll out of bed at 9 a.m., which gave her enough time to prepare a bowl of Chobani Greek yogurt and fruit before her first online period at 9:30.
That extra sleep, endorsed by the American Academy of Pediatrics, paid dividends in multiple ways for Natalie and others.
Most of their online classes were asynchronous, meaning teachers would leave assignments, lesson plans and videos ahead of time for students through the school’s platforms, such as Schoology and Google Classroom.
Instructors did not require students to turn on their computers’ cameras, meaning Natalie and others could take notes, listen in and ask questions while eating — even in the comfort of their pajamas.
“Everyone had their cameras off,” Natalie said, “which was great for me. I didn’t have to worry about how I looked. I could just focus on class.”
And her grades? “Straight As,” she said.
Marcos, who will attend Banning High School, also in Wilmington, in August, had often been a C student, but last semester he got all B’s and A’s. He said he benefited from the ability to email his eighth-grade teachers as many questions as he liked without fear of bullying.
“I didn’t know what to think at first, but it seemed to work out,” Marcos said. “Maybe it’s because I’m a natural introvert.”
Natalie, who considers herself an extrovert, said she wants to go back when campuses reopen. She’ll be starting at the California Academy of Mathematics and Science in Carson and realizes the difficulty of making new friends “when you’re not at school.”
However, she also believes that the past three months of the academic year should serve as a wake-up call to schools.
“If you’re not embracing technology,” she said, “you’re not helping your students.”
On the other side of Los Angeles County, Sebastian, a sophomore at Loyola High School from East LA, said he feels like he has come into his own — while on his own.
He used to carry a lot of anxiety, Sebastian said — worries over being late to school, of getting snarky looks when he’d raise his hand in class again and again.
“Honestly, it is nice being home,” the teen said. “It’s a lot less stressful and easier to keep up with the work. Plus, with two hours of extra sleep, I’m much more energized.”
His brother, Benjamin, 12, also thrived at home. He and classmates teamed up to check each other’s work and complete assignments on time, thus leaving more time for video games.
“It’s a good way to keep your friends motivated, because everyone wants to play,” he said.
The surprising gains have been a relief to parents, but they now worry those advancements could be lost when campuses reopen.
Margaret Hernandez, Sebastian’s mother, said going back to past routines will be challenging.
“My sons do miss being out with their friends, but I don’t know if they can also go back to normal,” she said. “They’ve changed during this time.”
Her husband, Alex Hernandez, worries about kids missing out on social interaction.
“It’s great my sons and others are doing well online, but this is a generation that struggles communicating outside of gadgets and the internet,” he said.
Still, for some kids, even younger ones, school at home works.